Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California ruled that a proposed antitrust lawsuit against Samsung Electronics, SK hynix, and Micron Technology can proceed, rejecting the companies’ joint motion to dismiss. The case, Garciaguirre et al. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al., now moves toward discovery, with the defendants’ answers due no later than December 7, 2026.
What the Ruling Actually Means
Surviving dismissal clears a low bar; it establishes nothing about guilt.
The court found that the plaintiffs’ allegations plausibly allege coordinated conduct under Section 1 of the Sherman Act, the federal law that prohibits certain anticompetitive agreements that unreasonably restrain trade. Plausible is the operative word: the plaintiffs still must prove an unlawful agreement exists.
The Core Allegation
Plaintiffs claim the three manufacturers coordinated a supply pullback from consumer memory while pivoting to AI chips.
The lawsuit accuses Samsung, SK hynix, and Micron of coordinating a rapid reduction in conventional DRAM supply. That covers DDR4 and DDR5 memory, the type found in PCs, consoles, and smartphones. The complaint alleges the companies simultaneously shifted production capacity toward high-bandwidth memory (HBM), the memory architecture used in AI accelerators and high-performance server systems, generally considered more lucrative than conventional DRAM.
The plaintiffs argue that in a genuinely competitive market, at least one manufacturer would have increased conventional DRAM output to capture higher prices and market share, forcing rivals to respond. Instead, the complaint frames the companies’ nearly identical supply decisions as evidence of coordination, not independent market judgment.
The Questionnaire Detail
Customers across the industry allegedly received nearly identical surveys from all three companies at roughly the same time.
One piece of circumstantial evidence cited in the complaint: customers reportedly received nearly identical questionnaires from all three manufacturers at around the same time, asking how their ordered DRAM would be used. The plaintiffs present this as evidence the companies were coordinating how to allocate supply between consumer products and AI-related applications. The complaint also alleges that conventional DRAM prices rose by nearly 700%, though that figure is an unverified claim from the complaint, not a judicially established measure of retail prices , a reminder that consumers are often paying too much without realizing it.
The Defendants’ Argument
The companies say their production decisions were rational, independent responses to market conditions.
Samsung, SK hynix, and Micron argued that pivoting toward HBM was a logical, independent business decision given the economics of AI infrastructure demand. Judge Wise found that argument insufficient to dismiss the case at this stage, without finding it false.
Prior History
This industry has faced price-fixing allegations before, though history is context, not proof.
The DRAM sector carries relevant baggage. Samsung and Hynix pleaded guilty and paid criminal penalties in connection with a price-fixing cartel covering roughly 1998 to 2002, while Micron received immunity in that U.S. investigation. A separate 2018 class action alleging coordination during the 2016 to 2018 period was dismissed, and the Ninth Circuit later upheld that dismissal. Judge Wise declined to treat the new complaint as automatically barred by the earlier failed litigation, citing the combination of allegations specific to the current period.
What Comes Next
Discovery may test whether parallel decisions reflect illegal coordination or ordinary market incentives.
The case may turn on one critical legal distinction: parallel conduct, meaning companies making similar decisions independently in response to the same market conditions, versus concerted action, meaning an actual agreement. Discovery could surface production plans, internal communications, and capacity-allocation records that clarify which applies. No ruling so far imposes a production requirement or price remedy, and any consumer impact remains uncertain; the litigation may take substantial time to resolve.






























