Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook Camera-Roll Feature

Italy’s GPDP found that Android’s system permission prompt left 20 million users unaware of how Facebook used their photos

Nikshep Myle Avatar
Nikshep Myle Avatar

By

Image: Deposit Photos

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways

  • Italy’s GPDP fines Meta €805 million for enabling camera-roll access without informed consent.
  • Regulators ruled default-on activation strips meaningful user choice, requiring Meta to disable the feature.
  • Meta must obtain fresh, specific consent within 60 days or face continued regulatory enforcement.

€805 million. That is what Italy’s data-protection authority, the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali (GPDP), imposed on Meta Platforms Ireland over a Facebook feature that accessed Android users’ camera rolls and suggested stored photos and videos as potential posts.

The feature, called “Get camera roll suggestions when you’re browsing Facebook,” has been available since 2023. The GPDP said approximately 20 million Android users in Italy were affected, with ongoing exposure for those who had not updated the app or who had already granted system permission , a dynamic reminiscent of apps secretly tracking users without meaningful disclosure.

What the Regulator Actually Found

The GPDP’s core objection was not the existence of a permission prompt, but whether that prompt was specific enough to constitute informed consent.

“The company accessed photographs, videos and related metadata stored on Italian users’ smartphones via the Facebook app for Android devices without obtaining specific consent and without adequately informing them.” Italian Data Protection Authority (GPDP).

The question was not whether Android displayed a permission prompt. Regulators asked whether that prompt was specific enough, whether users understood the feature’s privacy implications, and whether a default-on setting stripped away any meaningful choice.

Default-On Is Not Neutral

The GPDP treated default activation as central to the consent failure, not as a minor interface detail.

Under Italian privacy rules, a feature that accesses sensitive personal content needs to earn its permissions rather than inherit them from a broad, app-level grant. Turning something on by default and waiting for users to object is not the same as asking them first.

What Meta Must Do, and When

Meta has 60 days to obtain fresh consent, disclose the feature’s purpose, and keep it disabled by default.

The company must obtain fresh, specific consent for the camera-roll feature through a separate request. It must explain clearly what the access is used for and how users can disable it. The feature must remain disabled by default, even for users who previously granted permission.

Meta must also report its planned initiatives to the GPDP within 30 days and the measures it has adopted within 90 days. A past permission does not automatically satisfy the new standard.

Meta’s Response

Meta called the fine disproportionate and said it would appeal, though the grounds and timetable are not yet known.

A Meta spokesperson told Deutsche Welle: “We strongly disagree with this decision and will appeal.” The company maintained that Android users must affirmatively grant permission and can adjust it through Facebook’s in-app settings. The available sources do not specify the grounds or timetable for the appeal.

How Large Is €805 Million, Really?

The fine’s scale differs slightly depending on the source, but both figures place it well below one percent of Meta’s global revenue.

The GPDP’s official documents describe the penalty as approximately 0.47 percent of Meta’s global turnover. Deutsche Welle reported the figure as roughly 0.4 percent, reflecting a different calculation. The investigation began in July 2025, prompted by a complaint from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti (CTCU), a consumer-protection organization based in Bolzano.

A Pattern of Legal Pressure

The Italian action is one of several significant legal proceedings Meta faces across different jurisdictions.

Separate from the Italian case, a New Mexico jury found Meta liable for more than 43 million violations of the state’s consumer-protection laws. A judge then ordered the company to pay $25 billion, per Reuters. That case involved alleged deception about Facebook data practices connected to Cambridge Analytica’s acquisition of user data through a third-party application, with jurors finding 26 of 29 statements by Meta and its leadership misleading.

These are distinct proceedings under different legal systems, involving different conduct and procedures. Europe Restricts major technology platforms across a range of data-protection concerns, and the Italian authority’s decision does not indicate any reliance on the New Mexico case.

What Android Facebook Users Should Do Now

The GPDP’s order requires Meta to rebuild consent for this feature, but users should not assume their existing settings already meet the new standard.

Android users running Facebook should check the app’s photo and media permissions and review in-app privacy settings for camera-roll suggestions. The order gives Meta 60 days to comply and requires clearer controls and separate consent going forward. A previous permission does not automatically reflect that standard, and users who want to limit Facebook’s access to their gallery should not wait for Meta to prompt them , reviewing your device permissions is one way to stay safe in an environment where data access often outpaces disclosure.

Share this

At Gadget Review, our guides, reviews, and news are driven by thorough human expertise and use our Trust Rating system and the True Score. AI assists in refining our editorial process, ensuring that every article is engaging, clear and succinct. See how we write our content here →