Ohio Proposal Could Let Data Center Developers Seize Private Land Through Eminent Domain

Ohio Farm Bureau warns a leaked Senate draft could let transmission developers seize farmland before compensation is settled

Al Landes Avatar
Al Landes Avatar

By

Image: Deposit Photos

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways

  • Leaked Ohio bill redefines “public utility,” potentially giving data-center infrastructure an eminent-domain path.
  • Ohio voters rejected data-center expansion across 21 ballot measures in 18 municipalities statewide.
  • Ohio Farm Bureau warns construction could begin before landowners receive final compensation under the draft.

A leaked Ohio draft bill would redefine “public utility” to include an agency holding an Ohio Power Siting Board certificate for an electric transmission line, associated facilities, or a gas pipeline. Legal experts cited in reporting by WCPO say that language could create an indirect path to eminent domain for infrastructure connected to data-center projects.

Voters Just Said No

The proposal arrives after a sharp and widespread public pushback against data-center development across the state.

Ohio voters recently considered 21 data-center-related ballot measures across 18 municipalities. Communities responded with bans, size limits, zoning changes, and financial guarantees on developers, according to reporting by WGTE and the Ohio Newsroom.

How Eminent Domain Works in Ohio Now

Under current law, a utility must clear several legal hurdles before it can acquire private land.

A utility first approaches a property owner with a market-price offer. If the owner refuses, the utility takes the matter to court, where it must establish the necessity of acquiring the land. Once a court agrees, the appraised value is deposited into a court account; the owner may still contest the final amount.

What the Draft Would Change

Critics say the revised possession process could shift leverage away from landowners before compensation is resolved.

The bill would also modify the appraisal and possession process, according to WCPO’s reporting on the leaked draft. The Ohio Farm Bureau warned that the changes could allow construction to begin before final compensation is determined, leaving landowners to wait months or years while litigation continues.

The Indirect Pathway

The concern identified by legal experts is not that data-center companies would gain new powers, but that their infrastructure partners might.

Under the draft as described, a data-center operator itself would not receive eminent-domain authority directly. The concern identified by legal experts in WCPO’s reporting is narrower: a transmission or pipeline developer connected to a data-center project could potentially use the expanded public-utility definition to pursue land needed to serve or locate that project.

What Sponsors Say

The bill’s author describes it as a procedural improvement that leaves existing property protections intact.

Republican state Sen. Bill Reineke said the bill is intended to simplify the existing process, hold down utility rates, expand infrastructure, and protect landowners’ rights, according to WCPO. He said it would not extend eminent-domain authority to any entity that does not already hold it.

A Business Advocate’s Hesitation

The Ohio Business Roundtable’s own representative expressed uncertainty about one of the draft’s central provisions.

Alexandra Denney of the Ohio Business Roundtable said her organization did not intend to expand eminent-domain authority to entities that do not already possess it, according to WCPO. After being shown the draft’s revised public-utility language, she said she would need to review that specific provision.

Where the Farm Bureau Stands

Ohio’s leading farm advocacy organization draws a clear line between the data-center industry and the property-rights questions this bill raises.

The Ohio Farm Bureau said it does not oppose data centers as an industry, according to WCPO’s reporting. Its objection is to any change that could weaken property-rights protections or permit land to be taken before compensation and legal rights are fully settled.

Key Questions Still Open

The bill’s final form and legal effect remain uncertain, and the gap between stated intent and possible outcome has not been resolved.

The bill had not been formally introduced or assigned a bill number as of the available reporting. Whether the final version retains the leaked language, and whether that language would independently confer new eminent-domain authority, remain unconfirmed. Whether a transmission project serving a private data center could satisfy Ohio’s public-use and necessity standards is an additional legal question that the available reporting does not answer.

Share this

At Gadget Review, our guides, reviews, and news are driven by thorough human expertise and use our Trust Rating system and the True Score. AI assists in refining our editorial process, ensuring that every article is engaging, clear and succinct. See how we write our content here →