Meta has told a Canadian Senate committee that it may have to withdraw WhatsApp from Canada if Bill C-22 passes without changes addressing its encryption concerns. No withdrawal decision has been made, and no timetable exists.
Rachel Curran, Meta’s head of public policy for Canada, testified that the company would “review all of our options” if ordered to weaken its encrypted services, including the possibility of leaving the Canadian market.
Robyn Greene, Meta’s director of privacy and public policy, addressed the technical question directly. Greene said compliance with the bill as currently written is not feasible while maintaining end-to-end encrypted services, which are designed so that only the people in a conversation can read its contents.
What Bill C-22 Would Require
The legislation would give authorities new tools to compel technology companies to assist with investigations, including powers that critics say could threaten encryption.
Bill C-22 would require technology companies to adapt their systems so they can provide information to investigators acting under a warrant. It also gives the public safety minister authority to issue confidential orders requiring electronic service providers to build surveillance or monitoring capabilities into their systems.
Meta has flagged a specific provision that could require companies to retain customer metadata for up to six months. Curran described that requirement as creating what amounts to a broad surveillance database and warned that any such pool of retained data becomes an attractive target for hackers.
Meta’s Position on Encryption
The company has drawn a firm line, saying it will not comply with any order that requires it to compromise WhatsApp’s security protections.
Curran told the committee that Meta would not weaken, break, or undermine WhatsApp’s encryption protections and would refuse any order requiring it to do so. That position is Meta’s stated policy, presented to senators as a condition of the company’s continued operation in the Canadian market.
The Government’s Response
Ottawa says the bill contains safeguards against indiscriminate surveillance, but critics dispute whether those assurances are sufficient.
The government’s stated position is that the bill does not authorize indiscriminate surveillance and does not require companies to introduce systemic vulnerabilities or backdoors. Critics, including Meta and Signal, argue that the authority to order providers to build monitoring capabilities into their systems poses security risks. They contend that risk exists regardless of how those orders are framed.
Broader Industry Opposition
Several major technology companies have aligned against the bill, warning that its surveillance provisions are incompatible with secure encrypted services.
Signal has issued a parallel warning, stating it would leave Canada rather than compromise its encryption protocol. Apple and Alphabet have also joined industry efforts urging Ottawa to amend the bill before it becomes law, though the specific form of their participation has not been confirmed by a primary joint submission or testimony record.
Where the Bill Stands
Bill C-22 has cleared the House of Commons and is now under committee consideration in the Senate, where industry stakeholders are pressing for amendments.
The outcome carries consequences beyond Canada’s borders. If Ottawa preserves the bill’s surveillance powers, privacy-focused services could face choices including compliance, system redesign, litigation, or withdrawal from the Canadian market. If Parliament narrows those powers, law-enforcement agencies could lose some of the digital investigative access they have sought. No amendments have been adopted, and no Senate vote has been scheduled.






























