NYC Pulls Generative AI From 600,000 Students’ Classrooms

Mayor Mamdani and Schools Chancellor Samuels cite lack of evidence as five supervised AI pilots continue at the high school level

Rex Edison Avatar
Rex Edison Avatar

By

Image: Deposit Photos

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways

  • NYC bans generative AI for 600,000 students in grades 2-K through 8 starting 2026.
  • Disable AI components across 38 approved programs while permitting five supervised high school pilots.
  • Officials cite weak evidence for AI benefits in young learners, prioritizing critical-thinking development.

Starting in the 2026–2027 school year, roughly 600,000 New York City public school students in grades 2-K through 8 will generally be prohibited from using student-facing generative AI tools, under a moratorium announced by Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Schools Chancellor Kamar H. Samuels. The measure affects approximately two-thirds of the city’s public school system, according to the NYC Mayor’s Office.

What the Moratorium Actually Restricts

The prohibition targets direct student interaction with generative AI, not classroom technology as a whole.

The restriction applies to software that uses generative AI for instruction, tutoring, or other direct student interaction. Companion chatbots are prohibited across every grade level, including high school. AI components in more than 38 previously approved programs will be disabled or discontinued, according to the NYC Mayor’s Office.

Screen Time Gets Recommended Limits Too

Device limits accompany the AI restrictions, with specific guidance tied to grade level.

Individual device use is prohibited for students in 2-K through second grade. For grades 3–5, NYCPS recommends no more than 30 minutes of daily one-to-one screen time; for grades 6–8, the recommended daily limit is 45 minutes, per NYCPS policy guidance.

Exceptions Built Into the Policy

Certain students retain access to approved tools under specific, supervised conditions.

Limited carve-outs exist for students with disabilities, English-language learners, and those in coding or career-readiness programs. Those exceptions are subject to applicable school guidance and supervision, according to the NYC Mayor’s Office.

High School Operates Under Different Rules

Older students are not subject to the blanket moratorium but remain limited to approved, supervised use.

High school students fall outside the grades 2-K through 8 moratorium, though their access to student-facing AI is still restricted to defined, approved purposes. NYCPS has approved five centrally supervised pilots using vetted platforms: Quill, Edia, Brisk Teaching, Playlab, and Intel AI-Ready Schools. Pilot use is capped at 45 minutes per week under direct teacher oversight, according to NYCPS policy guidance.

AI Literacy Still Has a Place in High School

Every high school student will complete two structured modules on how AI works and where it falls short.

All high school students will receive two 45-minute AI-literacy modules during the school year. The curriculum addresses how AI works, data privacy, bias, critical thinking, and appropriate use in school settings, according to NYCPS policy guidance.

What Teachers Can and Cannot Do

AI remains a planning tool for educators, with firm limits on grading and student assessment.

Teachers may use AI for lesson planning and operational tasks that comply with NYCPS safety standards. Grading and assessment are prohibited uses, as are care, counseling, behavioral monitoring, and student-placement decisions, per NYCPS guidance.

The Rationale Behind the Restriction

City officials cited a lack of strong evidence for generative AI’s benefit to young learners as the central justification.

Mayor Mamdani and Chancellor Samuels framed the policy around preserving teacher-student relationships and ensuring students build critical-thinking skills without premature reliance on AI tools. Officials also expressed skepticism about adopting industry-backed claims for young learners without stronger supporting evidence, according to the NYC Mayor’s Office.

A Review Is Already Scheduled

A coalition of educators, parents, and students will examine the policy before the next school year begins.

NYCPS has convened a Technology in Schools Coalition that includes educators, parent leaders, students, and other partners to gather input on the moratorium’s effects. The coalition’s work is expected to inform NYCPS policy for the 2027–28 school year, according to NYCPS guidance.

Share this

At Gadget Review, our guides, reviews, and news are driven by thorough human expertise and use our Trust Rating system and the True Score. AI assists in refining our editorial process, ensuring that every article is engaging, clear and succinct. See how we write our content here →