Israel Uploaded 3.5 Million Palestinian Photos to Amazon Rekognition

Israeli military unit Rolling Stone moved 3.5 million Palestinian images to AWS in early 2024 under the $1.2 billion Project Nimbus contract

Al Landes Avatar
Al Landes Avatar

By

Image: Deposit Photos

Key Takeaways

Key Takeaways

  • Israel’s Rolling Stone unit uploaded 3.5 million Palestinian photos to Amazon Rekognition in 2024.
  • Project Nimbus, a $1.2 billion AWS and Google contract, enabled large-scale Israeli military AI use.
  • Facial recognition reportedly misidentified civilians as militants, raising unresolved oversight and accountability concerns.

3.5 million photographs of Palestinians were uploaded to Amazon Rekognition by an Israeli military department in early 2024, during Israel’s ongoing campaign in Gaza, according to an investigation by The Guardian. This follows a broader pattern of state-linked surveillance app deployments documented in recent years.

The upload was carried out by a unit known as “Rolling Stone,” which operates within an Israeli military software division. The unit maintains extensive records on Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank, covering identity photographs, family relationships, property records, checkpoint crossings, permits, and alleged criminal activity.

Rolling Stone reportedly used Amazon Rekognition, the company’s commercial facial-recognition and image-analysis service, to explore processing those large image collections. Whether the upload was used in live operations or remained at the experimental stage has not been established.

Israeli forces reportedly set up temporary checkpoints across Gaza following the October 2023 ground invasion, where cameras captured images of Palestinians and compared them against Rolling Stone’s records. Anonymous military sources cited the “very large scale” of the image collections as the reason AWS infrastructure was required.

The arrangement sits inside Project Nimbus, a 2021 contract under which Amazon and Google provide cloud storage, computing, and artificial-intelligence capabilities to Israeli government and defense institutions. Widely reported accounts value the contract at approximately $1.2 billion. AWS opened data centers near Tel Aviv in early 2023, and documents reviewed by The Guardian indicate Rolling Stone migrated major databases, including photographs, videos, and classified intelligence material, into that environment.

Rekognition was reportedly also used in the early weeks of the war to help identify hostages taken during the Hamas-led October 7, 2023 attack and to flag individuals the military suspected of being militants. The New York Times previously reported that Israeli facial-recognition experiments in Gaza sometimes misidentified civilians as militants, though that reporting described a broader program and did not establish that every system involved was Amazon Rekognition.

AWS told The Guardian it has no visibility into customer workloads stored in its cloud and declined to discuss its relationship with the Israeli military without customer consent. The company characterized visits by a small group of Israeli soldiers to its Tel Aviv offices in early 2024 as routine customer engagement. The Israel Defense Forces, as reported by The Guardian, declined to comment on services related to operational needs.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation has called for public disclosure about the roles Amazon and Google play under Project Nimbus, arguing that the contract may facilitate surveillance and unlawful data collection involving Palestinians. Critics contend that cloud providers cannot treat infrastructure as a neutral service. The argument centers on the storage, computing capacity, and AI tools that enable large-scale biometric systems. These are advocacy positions; the available reporting identifies no independent legal finding that specific AWS workloads violated international law.

Several questions raised by the reporting remain unresolved. Whether the 3.5 million images came from Gaza checkpoints, pre-existing identity databases, or a combination of sources has not been established. Whether facial-recognition matches from that specific upload influenced detention, interrogation, or targeting decisions is unknown, and what data-retention, access-control, and deletion rules governed the images remains equally unclear. Whether people photographed at checkpoints had any avenue to contest an identification is also unknown, echoing broader concerns raised in cases of secretly tracking users without meaningful recourse.

Share this

At Gadget Review, our guides, reviews, and news are driven by thorough human expertise and use our Trust Rating system and the True Score. AI assists in refining our editorial process, ensuring that every article is engaging, clear and succinct. See how we write our content here →