Written By:
Our posts contain affiliate links. Sometimes, not always, we may make $$ when you make a purchase through these links. No Ads. Ever. Learn More
Table of Contents_
To find the air fryer toaster ovens, you’ll need to determine the features that are right for you and your culinary setup. We recommend that you favor ovens with true hybrid functionalities, excelling at both toasting and air frying. Make sure to also consider how powerful the toaster oven actually is and how much space is available for ingredients. When buying an air fryer toaster oven, always look for a durable build, plenty of internal room, and a powerful and versatile heating element.
After analyzing hundreds of reviews amongst a multitude of products with varying price points and features, we’ve determined that the Ninja SP101 Foodi is the best air fryer toaster oven on the market today. After you’re finished reading about this product, visit our top toaster oven guide to learn more about the best ovens on the market.
Award: TOP PICK
WHY WE LIKE IT: Best air fryer oven with a suite of robust features, including a powerful 1800-watt heating element, a dehydration feature, and durable stainless steel components running throughout.
This Ninja air fryer toaster oven is a great choice for families, as the generous maximum capacity can easily accommodate nine slices of bread or even a 13-inch pizza. We loved the durable stainless steel components and the ultra-powerful 1800-watt heating element, which preheats quickly and efficiently. We also liked that this best toaster oven is highly versatile, allowing for dehydration, broiling, and other cooking methods.
Though we appreciated this toaster’s unique flip-up design, it is on the bulkier side for storage and cleaning purposes, so make sure you have enough room set aside. Additionally, this is a slightly heavier-than-average toaster, at over 16 pounds. It’s an incredible product for anyone looking for the best microwave toaster oven combo with all the bells and whistles.
Award: HONORABLE MENTION
WHY WE LIKE IT: Great choice for families looking for a nifty all-in-one cooking solution, as this combo unit features six independent quartz heating elements, for temperature precision, and a maximum capacity that can accommodate a 14lb turkey, among other large ingredients.
This Breville smart air fryer toaster oven is a great option for consumers looking for a versatile all-in-one kitchen solution, as this air fryer toaster oven boasts 13 programmable cooking functions to suit a wide variety of recipes, including options for dehydration, cookies, bagels, slices of toast, and more. We loved the generous capacity here, as this unit can easily handle a 14-pound turkey. Plus, there are six independent quartz heating elements. These heating elements allow for ultra-precise temperature control and excel at broiling, among other tasks.
Though the large max capacity was much appreciated, this is an extremely heavy model, clocking in at a whopping 40 pounds. Also, the preheating element can be on the slower side, as it takes up to 20 minutes to reach the maximum temperature of 480F. If the size is an issue, our best small toaster oven buying guide also has more options.
Award: BEST QUALITY
WHY WE LIKE IT: High-quality air fryer toaster oven with some serious features, such as a powerful and precise 1800w heating element and the option for a lower-than-average temperature setting, for the purposes of braising, slow cooking, and more.
This Cuisinart air fryer toaster oven is of exceptional quality with a serious feature set that includes a powerful 1800-watt heating element and a wide temperature range that can vary from just 80F all the way up to 450F. The lower temperature settings are great for slow cooking, braising, and dehydration, and there is even a dedicated function for proofing dough. We appreciated the durable stainless steel form factor as well.
Though we liked the non-stick coating throughout the interior, making for easy cleanup, certain consumers may not like the chemicals used to create this coating, so take that into consideration before making a purchase. This model is also on the expensive side, likely due to the robust features on offer. If you’re a baker and chef, this is one of the best kitchen appliances for you.
Award: BEST FOR BAKING
WHY WE LIKE IT: Features specialized presets for baking cakes and related foodstuffs, with a durable stainless steel form factor, a generous 18L maximum capacity, and shipping with numerous useful accessories, including items for making rotisserie chicken.
The Instant Omni Pro Air Fryer Toaster Oven is a great choice for those who don’t want to use a conventional oven for baking cakes and related baked goods, as this model boasts a wide range of presets for baking, among other useful types of cooking. We appreciated the generous maximum capacity here, 18 liters, which is large enough to handle a whole chicken. To that end, this air fryer toaster oven ships with a range of useful accessories, including a rotisserie spit, forks, and a lift.
Though the maximum capacity is certainly on point, this toaster is on the heavier side, at just over 30 pounds. Also, this is a somewhat expensive toaster, so take that into consideration before making a purchase. You might also want to take a look at our best convection microwave ovens buying guide for more affordable options with similar capabilities.
Award: BEST FOR WHOLE CHICKENS
WHY WE LIKE IT: This model features a large maximum capacity and ships with a rotisserie spit, making it the perfect choice for cooking whole chickens and boasting a durable stainless steel form factor.
The Emeril Lagasse Power 360 Air Fryer Toaster Oven is the perfect choice for preparing a perfectly cooked rotisserie chicken, as this model boasts more than enough room for a standard-sized bird and comes with a rotisserie spit, along with a motor to gently spin said chicken during the cooking process. We loved the robust number of presets available, suiting a wide range of recipes, and the durable stainless steel components running throughout.
Though we loved that this toaster can fit an entire chicken at one time, we must note that this model is on the bulkier side, so those with small kitchens take note. Additionally, the exterior of this unit can get really hot during use, so we advise caution. It’s a great choice for anyone looking for the best rotisserie toaster oven with air-frying capabilities.
Award: BEST SPACE-SAVING DESIGN
WHY WE LIKE IT: Compact and space-saving form factor that is perfect for smaller kitchens, with an easy-to-see viewing window that makes it easy to check in on how the cooking is going.
The Cuisinart TOA-60CRM Compact Air Fryer Toaster Oven is a fantastic option for consumers who have smaller-than-average kitchens, as this compact-sized model can squeeze in just about anywhere. We loved the integrated viewing window. We also liked the series of presets available and the 60-minute timer, which automatically shuts the toaster down when finished.
Though there are plenty of useful presets here, there is nothing available for dehydration, slow cooking, or braising. Also, the maximum temperature here is 450 degrees Fahrenheit, which may not suit those who like to broil at ultra-high temperatures. Great for anyone shopping for the best compact microwave, but wanting a few additional features.
Award: BEST FOR MEAT
WHY WE LIKE IT: Ships with a handy internal temperature probe, making this a great option for perfectly cooking meat and poultry, with an extremely light form factor, at just under ten pounds.
The NuWave Bravo XL Air Fryer Toaster Oven is a great choice for amateur chefs who are fearful of overcooking or undercooking meat or poultry, as this model ships with an integrated internal temperature probe, ensuring your favorite dishes are properly prepared. We loved just how light this toaster is, making it easy to move it around the kitchen at will. We also liked that the temperature can be easily adjusted via five-degree increments and that this model boasts a dehydration function, among other useful presets.
Though we liked the powerful quartz heating elements located throughout, this toaster can get extremely hot on the exterior during use, so we advise caution. Additionally, this model does not feature an integrated timer, so you’ll have to follow along with your phone or via some other method. You might also want to check out our best built-in microwave buying guide for similar options.
Award: BEST EASY-TO-CLEAN
WHY WE LIKE IT: Features a design that is made for easy cleaning, with a series of dishwasher-safe components, in addition to allowing for perfectly cooked rotisserie chicken, via a rotating basket.
The Instant Pot Vortex Plus Air Fryer Toaster Oven is designed for easy cleaning, thanks to a number of components that can be cleaned in the dishwasher, including the drip pan, cooking trays, rotisserie basket, rotisserie spit, and rotisserie forks. The sleek surface along the exterior also wipes clean, further streamlining the process. We appreciated the handy rotating basket, which is perfect for rotisserie chicken, and the integrated dehydration feature.
Though we appreciated how tall this toaster is, allowing for the cooking of full-sized chickens, it is not too wide, so you won’t be able to cook many slices of bread at once or a larger-than-average pizza. Also, the exterior can get pretty hot during use, and the company recommends keeping it at least five inches from a wall. You might want to consider our best 4-slice toaster oven if you need to toast more than one slice of bread.
Award: BEST ON A BUDGET
WHY WE LIKE IT: Budget-conscious hybrid oven with a suite of innovative features, including a large maximum capacity that can fit a 9” x 13” pan and a 60-minuter precision timer with automatic shutdown.
This Black and Decker air fryer toaster oven is available at a relatively low price while retaining a serious feature set that includes a generous maximum capacity that can easily fit a 9” x 13” pan. We loved the 60-minute precision timer, which automatically shuts the toaster down when cooking has finished, and the number of useful presets available. We also liked the easy-to-clean crumb tray, which easily slides out for a quick wiping down.
Though the temperature can easily be adjusted at will, the maximum temperature here is 450 degrees Fahrenheit, which may not suit all consumers. Also, there are no functions here for dehydration, slow cooking, or braising. We do have the best slow cooker buying guide if that feature is important to you.
Award: BEST VALUE
WHY WE LIKE IT: Value-friendly toaster with a bevy of high-grade features, such as a durable stainless steel form factor, a built-in timer, and the capacity to automatically shut down when cooking has been completed.
This Farberware Air Fryer Toaster Oven comes in at a value-conscious price while offering features in line with more expensive competitors, including a durable and thick stainless steel form factor. These stainless steel components allow the oven’s exterior to remain relatively cool during use. We loved the built-in 60-minute timer, which does allow for the option to shut down when the cooking process has been completed automatically.
Though this model does feature a number of useful presets to suit a variety of recipes, there are no presets for dehydration or slow cooking, which may be an issue for some. Additionally, this toaster lacks a light on the inside, which could severely impact visibility. For additional stainless steel options, our best stainless steel microwave buying guide has great options with diverse functionality.
To help narrow down the above list, we thoroughly researched a wide array of popular air fryer toaster ovens, ensuring that they excelled at traditional toasting tasks, baking, and air frying. To that end, we liked models with high-grade heating elements that could do double duty as a convection-based cooker and a circulation-based fryer.
As for size, we liked models with generous maximum capacities, large enough to fit a whole chicken or to cook an entire pizza. Bonus points were awarded to toasters that shipped with useful accessories, such as rotisserie spits for chicken. We also liked ovens that were exceptionally easy to clean, with removable crumb trays and dishwasher-safe components.
Versatility was also a must as we went about selecting our top picks, with special attention paid to models that could handle a wide variety of cooking tasks, including dehydration, slow cooking, braising, baking, air frying, defrosting foods like frozen pizza, and more. Finally, we liked relatively compact and light toaster ovens that could easily fit in even the smallest of kitchen spaces and save precious counter space.
