Mechanical Fan vs Electric Fan

Lawrence Bonk Profile image

Written By:

Updated August 29, 2022

If you are new to the world of cooling appliances, you may look to compare a mechanical fan vs an electric fan. Some of the best fans, after all, feature one of these two designs. So what are the main differences between the two fan types, and which is the best fit for your life? Keep reading to find out.

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • When referring to mechanical fans and electrical fans, you are typically discussing accessories for automobiles, such as the fan clutch, water pump, and fan shroud.
  • Mechanical fans are powered by the engine itself and tied to the engine RPM, whereas mechanical fans boast a dedicated power source.
  • Both types of clutch fans are susceptible to repair and maintenance concerns, so have a pro on standby.

Mechanical Cooling Fan vs Electric Fan

The main contrast between these two types of fans is how they receive power and send power to the motor, which in turn powers the fan blades. This is helpful when searching for the finest car fans. Why is that? Mechanical fans are primarily found in automobiles, so you won’t have to learn how to run a ceiling fan without electricity.

Insider Tip

No matter which you choose, be sure to keep an eye on the fan for any repair or maintenance issues.

However, electric fans are also available in automobiles, even if you are looking for a top-rated battery-operated fan. Here are more contrasts between the two types so you can make an informed decision, even if that decision means choosing the best USB fan.

Engine Power

Mechanical fans are powered by the engine, more or less, with the voltage coming straight from underneath the hood. Electric fans are powered by a dedicated electrical motor that has nothing to do with the car’s engine. This makes electric fans less powerful but makes them work independently from the engine. In other words, you can likely use a car’s electric fan even when the car is not running, but the same is not true for mechanical fans.

Repairs and Maintenance

Generally speaking, electric fans are easier to maintain and repair than mechanical fans, as they are not tied to any other systems in the car. This makes them fairly easy to remove, even by regular folks, whereas mechanical fans likely need a qualified professional to conduct any maintenance or repairs. However, both types are durable and sturdy, requiring very few repairs, if any.

Integration

Make sure to check with a professional to see which type of fan will integrate into your automobile. Not all cars are set up to handle mechanical fans, for instance, and some may have an issue with an electric fan, though that is unlikely. Just make sure to do your research before buying a car and buying a fan to go with that car, unless the automobile comes with the fan already installed.

STAT: An electric fan completely removes the mechanical load of spinning the fan from the engine. It places an additional draw on the electrical system, but this is a more efficient means of spinning a fan. (source)

Mechanical Fan Vs Electrical Fan FAQs

What type of cooling fan should I use?

It depends on your vehicle and if it already boasts a stock shroud. Mechanical fan clutches are more powerful but are tied to the engine.

Which type is best?

It depends on your needs, as there are multiple options, including a stock shroud, a dual fan setup, a factory clutch fan, and more. If you want to increase water pump speed, go with an electric water pump.

Which is best for your vehicle?

It truly depends on your personal needs and the integration requirements of your vehicle. If concerned about fuel economy, for instance, go with an electrical fan with a water pump. If you want more power, go with a clutch fan integrated with a water pump pulley.
Lawrence Bonk Profile image