Fake Elsevier Journals

Lawrence Bonk Profile image

Written By:

Updated October 27, 2022

If you have been keeping up with gossip in the scientific community, you may have heard about publishing giant Reed Elsevier. The company has been accused of publishing falsified academic journals. These are very much like fake reviews, unfortunately. Keep reading to learn more about these fake Elsevier journals.

KEY TAKEAWAYS:

  • Scientific and academic publisher Reed Elsevier released six journals that were found to feature falsified peer reviews.
  • These peer reviews were paid for by pharmaceutical companies, including pharma giant Merck.
  • Elsevier has also been involved in other scandals, including being accused of publishing racist content.

What is Reed Elsevier?

Elsevier is a Netherlands-based publishing company that specializes in scientific, technical, and medical journals. It is a part of a larger conglomerate called RELX Group, though, until 2015, it was known as Reed Elsevier.

Insider Tip

Elsevier is a Netherlands-based publishing company that specializes in scientific, technical, and medical journals.

What did Elsevier do?

During the years 2000 to 2005, the publishing giant released six falsified medical journals, rumored to have been at the behest of pharmaceutical companies. These journals were made to look like peer-reviewed academic studies but were actually completely made up. It was never released which pharmaceutical companies put them up to this, but these journals were essentially “paid advertisements” for the pharma industry. Pharmaceutical giant Merck has been rumored to be behind at least one fake journal that featured a paid peer review. This is common even with app purchases online, like the fake Google Play Store’s fake reviews.

Fake reviews are no good, but real product reviews are important to your business. While buying reviews is easy, it’s even better to get bloggers to review your product or service.

Did the Company Receive any Penalties?

Not really, though the company did release an apology letter as soon as the allegations came to light. They also promised that the practice would cease immediately and that anyone involved with falsifying academic journals would be terminated. As of this writing, there are no records as to if they kept their word regarding the firings. They did, however, release several retraction notices and issued some updates to their publishing policies. Additionally, they changed how they conduct the peer-review process and how they interact with their editorial board.

Though it must be noted, multimedia conglomerate RELX Group eventually gobbled up the company. The publishing giant is still in operation, accounting for nearly 40 percent of its parent company’s profits.

Has Reed Elsevier Ever Been Accused of Anything Else?

Yes. A lot, actually. According to the BBC, in 2009, Elsevier offered Amazon vouchers to academics if they would go on Amazon and related e-commerce sites and give certain books the highest possible rating. Elsevier responded by stating, “Encouraging interested parties to post book reviews isn’t outside the norm in scholarly publishing, nor is it wrong to offer to nominally compensate people for their time.” But this is a thin legal line to play around on, just like the Glassdoor fake reviews case.

Additionally, two Elsevier journals, Intelligence and Personality and Individual Differences, have been accused of staffing scientists that promote certain racist scientific ideologies. These journals have been criticized for having “occasionally including papers with pseudoscientific findings of intelligence differences between races.” The company retracted the articles in question after the criticism came about.

Insider Tip

During the years 2000 to 2005, the publishing giant released six falsified medical journals, rumored to have been at the behest of pharmaceutical companies.

F.A.Q.

Is Elsevier credible?

Within certain academic circles, Reed Elsevier has perhaps the worst reputation imaginable. This is due to the aforementioned scandals and various company practices that have been frustrating to academics.


Is Elsevier free?

The company releases some articles for free, but the large majority of their journals must be purchased at a premium by academics and academic institutions.


Is Elsevier credible?

Not according to many academic institutions. For instance, the University of California recently dropped the publishing giant, and many other schools followed suit. Despite these hurdles, the company still continues to rake in big bucks.

If you want to read more about companies that had false reviews, check out this story about the Hindawi Publishing Corporation.



STAT: In a study of apps that have been flagged for fake reviews, games represented 41% of those singled out. (source)

Lawrence Bonk Profile image