Best →

Best Reusable Keurig Cups in 2022

Justin Caldwell Profile image

Written By:

Updated August 23, 2022

A reusable Keurig cup allows you to customize your single cup brewer beyond what is offered in disposable K cups. You can use your favorite coffee grounds, they’re easy to clean, and they’re durable enough for hundreds, if not thousands, of uses. They also eliminate waste because you can compost your used grounds and reuse the cup.

Reusable Keurig cups are affordable and versatile enough to use with many different types of grinds. The large variety of mesh sizes and compositions gives you plenty of options to choose from, and you can even use them for loose tea. They’ll save you money over disposable coffee pods and are a great option for any single cup brewer.

Read our buying guide to learn more about reusable Keurig cups and how they work. And if you’re in the market for a new brewer, check out our picks for the best coffee makers.

Top Reusable Keurig Cups

 #1  Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Keurig Cup

Award: TOP PICK

WHY WE LIKE IT: This model features nearly full compatibility with the leading single-serve machines and a multi-component construction that makes it simple to clean. With a locking lid and a fine mesh strainer, users will love strong cups of brew without much mess.

Pros
  • Amazing compatability
  • Easy to clean
  • Good filtration
Cons
  • No support for paper filters

The Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Keurig cup is an excellent pick for users who want an easy way to add their favorite coffee to their Keurig pod machine. This reusable Keurig filter lets users branch out from prefilled pods to find specialty and small-batch beans for their morning cup. Additionally, this model features a multi-component construction for easy cleaning and full compatibility for all Keurig 2.0 machines. While this model doesn’t allow for paper filters, its fine mesh filter and sturdy filter holder keep most grounds out of your mug.

In addition to fantastic device compatibility and easy cleaning, the Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Keurig cup is great for double or single-strength mugs of coffee. With two fill lines and a wide mouth, users can accurately measure the grounds for their ideal cup. Additionally, this device is perfect for single cups or travel mugs of fresh brew. Lastly, this reusable pod filter is easy to clean by hand, and it is dishwasher safe on the top rack.

 #2  Keurig 5048 Reusable Keurig Cup

Award: HONORABLE MENTION

WHY WE LIKE IT: This model offers a durable and multi-component design to deliver a unit that is dishwasher safe and simple to clean by hand. Users will love the wide compatibility and the ability to add their favorite gourmet beans to their single-serve machine.

Pros
  • Easy to clean
  • Great filtration
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • No Keurig 2.0 compatability

The Keurig 5048 reusable Keurig cup is a great pick for users who want to add their favorite beans to their Keurig home brewer. This model features a three-part system that makes it easy to clean and simple to fill with fresh grounds. Additionally, users will love the fine mesh filter that keeps loose grounds from seeping into their mugs, and it is big enough to take paper filters. While this model isn’t compatible with Keurig 2.0 machines, users can enjoy fresh grounds in the Keurig Elite and Ultra.

In addition to decent device compatibility and a great mesh filter, the Keurig 5048 reusable Keurig cup is simple to clean for users in a hurry. This model is completely dishwasher safe, or users can easily rinse this coffee pod after each brewing cycle. Additionally, thanks to being a first-party product, this model accurately fits compatible Keurig models. Lastly, the locking lid and filter holder are great for holding loose grounds in place and minimizing coffee spills.

 #3  NOALTO Reusable Keurig Cup

Award: BEST FOR SIMPLE DRINKS

WHY WE LIKE IT: Users will love the metal design and fine-straining holes that make this model great for freshly ground beans and easy cleanup. Thanks to multi-brand compatibility and simple operation, this model is a great all-around pick.

Pros
  • Durable design
  • Great compatability
  • Easy to clean
Cons
  • Not ideal for fine grounds

The NOALTO reusable Keurig cup is a stellar pick for users that need a reliable and eco-friendly way to enjoy single-serve mugs from their Keurig machine. This model features an incredible level of compatibility for Keurig 1.0 and 2.0 machines. Additionally, this model supports other brands like Hamilton Beach, Mr. Coffee, and Cuisinart for users who want to take this filter between multiple machines. While this model isn’t ideal for finely ground coffee or espresso beans, it is compatible with paper pod filters.

In addition to wide device compatibility, the NOALTO reusable Keurig cup features stainless steel construction that will hold up to tons of use, and it is BPA, lead, and DEHP-free. Additionally, this model is simple to wipe down after a brew, and it is dishwasher safe for moments when users need to save time. Lastly, this model accepts up to two tablespoons per brewing cycle and the lid fits tight to avoid spills.

 #4  YEOSEN Reusable Keurig Cup

Award: BEST FOR A STRONG BREW

WHY WE LIKE IT: This model features a locking top, a tight fit, and easy cleaning to offer a device that works with a ton of pod-based brewers and minimizes mess. With durable construction and decent filtration, users will love this brewing accessory.

Pros
  • Impressive design
  • Tight lid
  • Easy to clean
Cons
  • Sub-par filtration

The YEOSEN reusable Keurig cup is a great pick for users who want a super-compatible reusable pod filter that is simple to use without much mess. This model features a tight-fitting lid and safety grips so users can easily remove this pod after brewing without worrying about burns or spills. Additionally, this model is stainless steel and BPA-free so users can enjoy fresh and clean coffee. While the filter holes can let some coffee grounds through, users can easily apply a paper filter or utilize coarser grounds to avoid cloudy mugs.

In addition to a durable design and safety features, the YEOSEN reusable Keurig cup offers an easy-to-operate accessory that expands the flavor options in a Keurig machine. Thanks to the wide mouth and flip-lid, this model is easy to fill and lock tight. Additionally, the stainless steel construction makes this product simple to rinse clean, and it is dishwasher safe on the top rack.

 #5  Keurig 5000351186 Reusable Keurig Cup

Award: BEST FOR FLAVOR

WHY WE LIKE IT: This model features excellent extraction and durable construction so users can enjoy strong and aromatic mugs from their coffee pod machine. Thanks to being simple to deconstruct and dishwasher safe, users will love the ease of brewing their favorite beans.

Pros
  • Fantastic flavor
  • Wide compatibility
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Instructions are a bit unclear

The Keurig 5000351186 reusable Keurig cup is a fantastic pick for users looking for strong flavor and aromatic freshness from their single-serve pod brewer. This model features MultiStream technology so users can have the best possible results from the fresh grounds they put through their Keurig. Thanks to the multi-component design that features multiple adapters, this model works with all Keurig home coffee makers. While the instructions are a bit unclear for new users, all of the parts easily fit together without issue.

In addition to flavor preservation and wide compatibility, the Keurig 5000351186 reusable Keurig cup offers expanded coffee options compared to default pods. Additionally, this model is simple to use thanks to a removable lid and a clearly–marked max-fill line that allows for accurate measurements and mess-free filling. Lastly, this model is BPA-free and dishwasher safe so users can enjoy premium coffee without a difficult cleanup.

 #6  Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Keurig Cup

Award: BEST FOR QUICK BREWS

WHY WE LIKE IT: Users will love this model thanks to easy cleaning and strong filtration that won’t leave their mugs filled with stale or foggy brews. Additionally, this model features durable construction and simple operation that so users can enjoy fresh mugs during a busy morning.

Pros
  • Impressive filtration
  • Simple operation
  • Easy cleaning
Cons
  • Only compatible with Keurig 1.0

The Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Keurig cup is a stellar choice for users who want to expand their coffee horizons while enjoying fast mugs of coffee from their pod brewer. This model offers simple-but-durable construction that will hold up to many brew sessions. The removable lid makes filling the pod easy, and users will love how simple it is to clean after a brewing cycle. While this model is only compatible with Keurig Classic and 1.0, it allows for up to 12oz brew sizes.

In addition to easy operation and simple cleaning, the Keurig My K-Cup Universal Reusable Keurig cup has great filtration that keeps coarse grounds from muddying your mug. The fine mesh cup is great for coarse grounds, and it is big enough for paper filters if users want further filtration. Additionally, this model is simple to clean and it is dishwasher safe for users who want to save some time during a busy day.

Beginner’s Guide to Reusable Keurig Cups

What is a Reusable Keurig Cup

A reusable Keurig cup is a small reusable coffee filter basket that fits inside a single cup brewer. It holds coffee grounds of your choice and it can be washed and reused. Rather than using disposable coffee pods, many people choose reusable cups because they’re better for the environment. There’s much less waste since you aren’t disposing of a plastic pod, and you can compost the coffee grounds when you’re done.

Reusable Keurig Cups vs Standard Keurig Cups

Reusable Keurig cups fit in single-cup brewers just like standard coffee pods, but rather than being made of disposable materials, they’re made with reusable plastic and fine wire mesh. They hold enough coffee grounds for a single cup and can be washed and reused rather than thrown away after every use.

They also allow for customization in brew strength compared to a standard Keurig cup. You can fill it with as much or as little coffee as you like to achieve the perfect balance for your cup. You can also use your own grounds, which means you can use something that might not be offered in a pod. That’s why you can use it with your best 5-cup coffee maker.

It also gives you the freedom to purchase beans and grind your own coffee, which leads to a much better flavor overall. Of course, if you’re interested in stronger coffee or more specialized beverages, check out the best semi-automatic espresso machine.

Another benefit of using a reusable Keurig cup is that it saves you money compared to coffee pods. On average, a package of coffee grounds equivalent in price to a package of K cups will last twice as long. So you can use them with an office coffee maker, a smart coffee maker, and even some of the quietest coffee makers.

How a Reusable Keurig Cup Works

A reusable Keurig cup is very easy to use. Flip up the coffee maker’s lid, fill the cup with your grounds, close the lid, and insert it into your Keurig coffee maker or single-cup brewer. Brew your coffee like normal. When you’re done, remove the cup, dispose of the used grounds inside, and clean the cup so it’s ready for the next use. Speaking of grounds, if you don’t want to use a separate device for grinding, you’ll want a great espresso machine with a grinder.

Reusable K-cups are designed with a recessed bottom, so they fit in most single-cup brewers of any brand. Because they fit regardless of orientation, you can simply drop it in the machine in any direction and close the lid to begin brewing.

They’re also made with materials that are durable and easy to clean. The high-quality plastic and stainless steel mesh will withstand the high temperatures and water pressure inside the machine. Cleanup is as easy as dumping the grounds and rinsing the cup when you’re finished. When it needs a more thorough cleaning, many brands allow you to put it in the dishwasher. If not, you can clean it with warm water and mild dish soap.

Why should you buy a Reusable Keurig Cup?

Reusable Keurig cups are a necessity for anyone with a single cup brewer at home. The savings you’ll see by using ground coffee instead of pre-filled pods make them worth the purchase. And if you’re thinking of buying a single-serve coffee machine, a reusable filter like this is an accessory we recommend you consider. For more about this machine, you’ll want to learn how to use a pour-over coffee maker.

Is a Reusable Keurig Cup Worth Buying?

  • They’re versatile: You can use a reusable Keurig cup with many different types of coffee grounds and loose tea. This means you can brew a single cup of your favorite morning beverage even if it doesn’t come in a coffee pod. You can use grounds you buy at the store or grind your own specialty beans, and you have better control of your brew strength this way.
  • They’re durable: Reusable Keurig cups are made with high-quality plastic and stainless steel mesh, so they’re durable enough to withstand the high temperature and water pressure inside a single cup brewer and they’ll last for hundreds, if not thousands, of uses.
  • They reduce waste: By avoiding disposable K cups, you reduce your footprint on the environment. Because you can compost your coffee grounds and reuse the filter basket, there’s zero waste. Coffee grounds are biodegradable, so using them in the garden will give nutrients back to the soil. Even if you throw your coffee grounds away, they take up much less space than a disposable pod and will eventually decompose.
  • They’re affordable: These little reusable K-cup filters are offered at very reasonable prices. Since they don’t cost a lot of money upfront, you can purchase several, and it won’t break the bank.
  • They save you money: You will also save money over time by purchasing coffee grounds rather than disposable K cups. Grounds will last a lot longer than a package of disposable cups, which means you’ll be spending less money.
  • They’re easy to use and clean: A reusable K cup is easy to use, and many of them are dishwasher safe, so they’re easy to clean. Even if they’re not dishwasher safe, they’re small and clean up with dish soap in the sink.

Why a Reusable Keurig Cup May Not Be For You

  • They don’t work for every type of beverage: If you’re a fan of hot cocoa, cider, or other types of beverages, you may not be able to use a reusable Keurig cup. In situations like these, you may need to purchase disposable pods. They also won’t typically work for espresso, so consider the best prosumer espresso machine if you want something more elaborate.

How Long Will a Reusable Keurig Cup Last?

A reusable Keurig cup will last several years. There’s no reason you can’t use a reusable K cup at least several hundred times. You may even be able to use it thousands of times if you take care of it properly and keep it clean. Depending on how many times per day you use it, it could last up to 5 years or longer. It’s a great companion to your single-cup brewer, which is one of the best coffee makers for a quick cup of coffee.

How to Choose the Best Reusable Keurig Cup

There are several factors to consider when choosing the right reusable Keurig cup for your needs. Compatibility is likely the most important, followed by capacity, material, mesh size, and accessories.

Reusable Keurig Cup Key Factors

1. Should I be worried about compatibility?

Unfortunately, a filter holder like this is not universal. Not every reusable K cup will work with every machine, but each manufacturer will list the machines it’s compatible with. Check this list before you buy. You may even find that even with a single manufacturer, the fit will differ, such as among the Keurig Mini, Keurig K-Mini, and Keurig 1.0 coffee machines.

2. What capacity do I need?

Two tablespoons or 10 grams of coffee grounds is typically enough for a 6-8 ounce cup of coffee. Still, you can make it stronger with a larger capacity cup.

However, it’s important to remember not to overfill a reusable Keurig cup. While more grounds will lead to stronger coffee, if you add too much, your coffee will be weak because the water can’t penetrate the grounds. It can also lead to a clogged head, which will prevent your machine from working altogether.

3. What material should I choose?

Reusable Keurig cups are made from plastic and stainless steel, but the ratio of plastic to stainless steel will vary among manufacturers. You need to choose models that are eco-friendly and have BPA-free plastic so there won’t be any leaching of chemicals into your coffee.

While some models have a plastic lid with a frame and mesh made of stainless steel, others will have a plastic lid and frame with only the mesh made of stainless steel. Some models have a solid stainless steel basket with perforated holes instead of mesh.

While all of these will work well, it ultimately comes down to personal preference. The more stainless steel, the more money you’ll spend, but it will likely last longer.

4. How do I determine mesh size?

The mesh size you need will be dependent on the type of grounds you use. The fine mesh works well with a finer grind and will give you a stronger flavor and keep grounds out of your coffee.

A wide mesh will work well with your coarse grounds and produces a better-tasting cup of coffee in machines that have longer extraction times. Because a coarse grind requires the water to penetrate the grinds for a longer period, a wide mesh will enable a more flavorful coffee extraction.

Your choice in the mesh will depend on your grind and the type of machine you have. For most people, a medium grind and a medium mesh work well because the final flavor relies on more than grind size and mesh size. That said, it may take some experimenting to figure out what works best for you.

5. Do I need any accessories?

Sometimes reusable K cups come with accessories, so you can choose whether you think you need these or not. They may come with paper filters or a scoop. While this reusable filter can prevent grounds in your coffee, it also increases waste, and it’s not necessary if you use a fine mesh. However, a coffee scoop can come in handy to ensure you don’t spill your grounds when trying to fill a small cup.

Best Reusable Keurig Cup FAQs

Do reusable K-Cups work in all Keurig coffee machine models?

Not all reusable cups work in all machines. It’s important to look into which machines the reusable cup is compatible with before you buy it.

Can I use regular coffee in a Keurig?

You can use any ground coffee you like in a Keurig if you use a refillable cup. It opens up your options beyond just what comes in coffee pods. You can grind your own beans fresh if you want the best tasting coffee out of your single serve brewer.

What coffee grind size goes into a reusable K-Cup?

Medium grounds are the best solution for your reusable K-cup, but you can also use coarse grounds if you prefer. Grounds that are too find can clog the needle, back up the machine, and make their way into your cup.

Why does my reusable K-Cup make weak coffee?

Grounds that are the wrong size can make your coffee too weak. It may also end up weaker than you like if you don’t fill the cup full enough. However, these cups can only hold so much, and if you fill it too full, you won’t achieve maximum extraction. You may also want to try darker roasts or bolder flavors for a stronger cup of coffee out of your Keurig machine.

Do you need filters for reusable K-Cups?

Most reusable K-cups have mesh filters that eliminate the need for a paper filter. However, some people still prefer to use a paper filter because they think it makes cleaner coffee and keeps loose grounds from getting into your cup.
Justin Caldwell Profile image