Our posts contain affiliate links. Sometimes, not always, we may make $$ when you make a purchase through these links. No Ads. Ever. Learn More
Table of Contents_
To select the best reusable baking cups, we looked at the following features: materials, heat limits, size, design, safety, and ease of use. While we focused exclusively on BPA-free silicone baking cups, we incorporated a range of sizes and designs to give you options depending on whether you’re a beginner or experienced baker. We were sure to include heat ratings so you can make an informed decision and highlight where you might have trouble cleaning certain cups because of their unique designs or shapes. And, when you’re ready to grab more culinary products, then you need to check out our reviewed kitchen products.
After considering all of the above, we nominated the AmazonBasics Reusable Silicone Non-Stick Baking Cups as our Top Pick. As well as being our favorite, this option is also our Best Budget. While it doesn’t have the largest number of cups in a set, we liked that these cups had the highest heat rating which is important for the forgetful baker. Keep reading to learn more about the rest of our top picks.
Award: TOP PICK
WHY WE LIKE IT: A simple, colorful 12-piece set of standard size silicone baking cups that are safe for up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit for basic cupcake projects.
Read Full Review: AmazonBasics Reusable Silicone Baking Cups
If you’re just starting to make the transition from traditional metal bakeware to silicone, then it’s best to start simple. We think the AmazonBasics Reusable Silicone Non-Stick Baking Cups is the best option for beginning bakers. While there are only 12 cups in the pack, we like that this is also the Best Budget option and that it can withstand temperatures up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. Avoid ruining your skin with the best rubber gloves that we’ve reviewed for you.
The AmazonBasics reusable silicone baking cups are standard size, measuring two inches wide at the base and 2.75 inches at the top and a height of 1.38 inches. If you’re tired of buying new paper liners for each muffin tin every time you bake, then you’ll like that these baking cups can double as liners for a standard cupcake pan, and that you can put these cups in the freezer, microwave, and oven, so there’s no need to use a muffin pan. Plus the bright colors and designs at the bottom of the silicone liners make these perfect for baking projects with little ones too. And as is standard with silicone bakeware, these cups are made from food-grade silicone and are dishwasher safe making them easy to clean. These baking cups are so handy, they’ll soon be part of your best cookware.
Award: HONORABLE MENTION
WHY WE LIKE IT: The only multipack in our guide with mini loaf molds and jumbo silicone muffin cups to cover a wide range of baking needs.
Once you get more comfortable with using silicone reusable baking cups, you might want to venture out beyond the standard cupcake cups. In that case, the IELEK Silicone Cupcake Liners Bundle is where you should focus your attention. This multipack is also our Best Quality because it’s the only option in our guide that includes jumbo silicone muffin cups and baking loaf molds, along with standard size cupcake cups.
In this 30-pack set, you get six jumbo cupcake molds, 12, standard cupcake molds, and 12 mini bread loaf molds. All of the molds are rated safe up to 446 degrees Fahrenheit and are safe for use in microwaves and the dishwasher. And as is standard, these molds are food-grade silicone and BPA-free with no chemicals unlike other silicone liners. If you need to upgrade your baking setup entirely, take a look at the best stainless steel cookware too.
Award: Best Shapes
WHY WE LIKE IT: A 24-piece set of baking cups with designs that are perfect for use in making chocolate molds and mini cakes.
Some people prefer more decorative cake styles where the tops of the cakes have intricate designs. We think the LetGoShop Silicone Cupcake Liners Reusable Baking Cups are ideal for people who prefer a more decorative cake top, or who need silicone molds for something other than traditional cupcakes or quiches. We like that these baking cups feature decorative cup bottoms such as flowers, stars, and hearts. But if you still want to make traditional cupcakes, there are standard cup sizes too. You’ll get six of each of the four shapes.
The LetGoShop reusable baking cups are rated for up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit and are great for a range of purposes including jelly, egg tart, and pudding molds. And as is usual, these are made from food-grade silicone, are also BPA free, and are rated safe for use in microwaves, ovens, and dishwashers. If you prefer to drink your desert, take a look at some of the best whiskey glasses currently on the market.
Award: Best Stand Alone
WHY WE LIKE IT: A large quantity of standard-sized baking cups from the New York Baking Company are great for baking a variety of dessert items.
The New York Baking Company is a popular brand for home bakers thanks to the quality and longevity of their products. We’re including their 24-piece set of standard size baking cups because these feature a rigid silicone exterior that makes them perfect to use without a cupcake pan. Simply place them directly on a baking sheet. These are durable so the sides won’t collapse under the weight of batter.
While these do have the lowest heat rating in our guide (400 degrees Fahrenheit), we do like that if you only want standard size cups, New York Baking Company has the largest amount of all our picks. These cups are also dishwasher safe, made of BPA-free food-grade silicone, and can be put in the microwave too. If you’re looking for something a bit healthier, check out the best melon baller to make snacking on fresh fruit convenient this summer.
Award: Best for Donuts
WHY WE LIKE IT: A complete 360-degree covered mold that’s perfect for making mini bundt cakes or fresh baked homemade donuts.
If you’re a fan of donuts but hate the markup or health implications of buying them from popular chains, then our final pick is going to be interesting for you. The To Encounter 24 Piece Silicone Molds Reusable Baking Cups can pull double duty as mini bundt cake molds or for donuts. As bundt cake molds, you get 24 individual molds that each measure 2 ¾ inches wide. Plus there are six unique designs (four molds per shape). But when paired together as 360-degree molds, you can make 12 donuts (two per shape).
Each mold can hold up to a half cup of batter. These baking cups are safe up to 446 degrees Fahrenheit and are made from food-grade silicone that is BPA-free and safe for use in dishwashers and microwaves. However, because of some of the shapes, some molds may be easier to clean than others. For your dinner needs, you might also want to pick up the best potato peeler.
Reusable baking cups are a lifesaver for home bakers that are tired of fighting with metal pans to clean them or release their baked goods. To create our guide, we looked at the following core features — materials, heat limits, size, design, and ease of use. All of the options in our guide are made from food-grade silicone and are all BPA-free. So, core aspects such as being non-stick or easier to clean than metalware are covered.
Heat limits are important if you want to prolong the lifespan of your reusable baking cups. Every pick in our guide clearly outlined their maximum heat allowance. While our #4 pick had the lowest rating, it was still 400 degrees Fahrenheit. But if you need to use these baking cups for something other than bread (i.e. mini meatloaves, etc.), then our Top Pick is your best bet since it can withstand heat up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.
Next, we looked at the baking cup sizes. Most baking cups will be available in a standard size which is usually a two-inch-wide base with a 2.75-inch wide opening and a cup that is around 1.25 to 1.5 inches tall. This is the case with our Top Pick, some of the cups from our Honorable Mention and #3, and our #4 pick. But if you want options, our Honorable Mention includes jumbo silicone muffin cups and mini baking loaf cups. Likewise, our #3 pick has cups with decorative bases and our #5 is a set of bundt molds.
And finally, we considered the ease of use factor. While silicone molds are generally easier to clean, options that include more decorative bottoms can be harder to clean since you’ll have difficulty cleaning tiny corners and folds that create those designs.