Best Plunger

If you’re looking for the best plungers for your toilet, tub or shower drain, check out our thoroughly researched list. We’ve compared specs and reviews to bring out the best and save you from throwing time and money down the drain. In making our selection we looked at durability, material quality, suction element size and ease of cleaning and value for the money.

Our top pick, the Neiko 60166A is a heavy duty graduated suction design with an aluminum handle so it’s easier to keep clean and harbors less bacteria than a wooden handled plunger. Read on for more of our top picks.

Top 7 Best Plungers

 #1  Neiko 60166A Plunger

Award: Top Pick

WHY WE LIKE IT: Graduated, all-angle suction for a tight seal in all kinds of toilet opening shapes makes this handy toilet plunger more effective and easier to use.

Pros
  • Rustproof aluminum handle
  • Cup designed not to invert
  • 4-step suction for different sized toilet openings
Cons
  • Not the least expensive plunger on the market
  • Doesn’t include storage bin

Simple but thoughtfully designed, this aluminum and rubber plunger from Neiko is just under 24” tall, which most find to be a convenient size, giving a good balance between leverage and precision. The Neiko toilet plunger benefits from a graduated suction cup with four different size steps, letting it acquire a tight seal in a broad range of toilet openings.

Thanks to its suction cup design, this plunger also avoids the common toilet plunger pitfall of turning inside out after plunging. A smooth inner surface helps keep the plunger rim from filling up with toilet water and lets it stay clean longer. While we are on the subject of toilets, the best toilet bowl cleaner will keep things clean and flowing smoothly.

 #2  Mr Clean Turbo Plunger and Bowl Brush Caddy Set

Award: Honorable Mention

WHY WE LIKE IT: Affordable and well designed, this plunger and toilet brush set comes with its own caddy that helps keep your bathroom floor clean.

Pros
  • Durable, rust free plastic and rubber
  • Caddy comes with non stick rubber base
  • Lets you keep plunger and brush off the floor
Cons
  • Plunger handle may be too short for some
  • Plunger may not fit in elongated toilet openings as well

A good value, this bathroom cleaning set includes a durable plastic and rubber plunger along with a toilet bowl brush and a two-place caddy. The caddy helps you keep your floor clean and stores the toilet brush and plunger more unobtrusively than just hanging them up or putting them on the floor. The handles are made of smooth plastic and the plunger suction cup is pliable rubber, making it easy to clean.

While the plunger gets good ratings for durability and effectiveness, some may find its 12.5-inch handle a little too short for their liking. The best toilet brush is another must-have toilet accessory for your home that you can’t live without.

 #3  Korky Universal Plunger

Award: Best for Elongated Toilets

WHY WE LIKE IT: The Korky Universal plunger has an ergonomic t-shaped handle for easier plunging, along with a suction cup shape designed to fit old and new low flow toilets.

Pros
  • Special head for improved suction
  • Rubber suction cup deforms easily for a perfect fit
  • Made in USA
Cons
  • Toilet water sometimes gets stuck in the plunger as it unfolds
  • Handle is shorter, at 16”, than our top pick, the Neiko

The Korky Universal plunger is designed to fit elongated toilets along with old and new low flow toilets as well as standard “round” toilet bowl openings. It features a beehive-shaped rubber suction element that’s more flexible than found on the typical cup shaped plunger. This lets it work just as well in the challenging, odd shaped outlets of low flow toilets.

The Korky toilet plunger, as seen on This Old House and elsewhere, is American-made and has a solid reputation for reliability. The handle is a little shorter than some may prefer, at just under 16”, but it does have an ergonomic T-shape which makes the work of plunging a little easier. Speaking of easier, keep your TP in reach with the best toilet paper holder.

 #4  Simplehuman Plunger and Caddy

Award: Best Design

WHY WE LIKE IT: This well designed Simplehuman toilet plunger comes with a clever “bandshell” style holder that lets you hide your plunger in plain sight and reduces drips and spills.

Pros
  • Innovative magnetic collar
  • Stainless steel handle
  • Durable suction element
Cons
  • May not fit some elongated toilets as well
  • More costly than most of the plungers on our list
  • Rust can be an issue on trim pieces

While it’s seldom the case that you’re tempted to think of a toilet plunger as “elegant,” the design of this hideaway simplehuman toilet plunger/caddy combo may change your mind. The plunger cover has a magnetic collar that securely grips the plunger’s stainless steel handle so you can stow it away without having to touch the cover itself, and you can transport the plunger and cover as one piece, saving your bathroom floor from drips and cutting down on your cleaning tasks.

The plunger itself is comfortable to use, with a generous 23-inch handle. The rubber suction element is rated well for durability though some users note it may not fit in all low flow or elongated toilets. Speaking of bathroom accessories, check out the best lighted makeup mirror for the best view you will ever have while grooming.

 #5  Simplehuman Toilet Plunger and Caddy-Black

Award: Best Stainless Steel

WHY WE LIKE IT: Just like our #4 pick, this cleverly designed toilet plunger can be hidden in plain sight and carried around without drips. Depending on your bathroom decor scheme, you may prefer it in black or white.

Pros
  • Black finish & innovative magnetic collar
  • Stainless steel handle contrasts nicely against the steel finish
  • Durable suction element
Cons
  • May not fit some elongated toilets as well
  • More costly than most of the plungers on our list
  • Rust can be an issue on trim pieces

Like the Simplehuman plunger in white, the design of this black and silver hideaway simplehuman toilet plunger/ caddy combo may make you consider a toilet plunger to be a decor item. The plunger cover has a magnetic collar that securely grips the plunger’s stainless steel handle so you can stow it away without having to touch the cover itself, and you can transport the plunger and cover as one piece, saving your bathroom floor from drips and cutting down on your cleaning tasks.

The plunger itself is comfortable to use, with a generous 23-inch handle. The rubber suction element is rated well for durability though some users note it may not fit in all low flow or elongated toilets. Now when it comes to fixing other parts of the bathroom, replacing the best shower curtain is easy and we can help with that too.

 #6  Good Grips Toilet Plunger and Canister

Award: Easiest to Store

WHY WE LIKE IT: A hideaway canister with built-in drying tray makes this one of the most convenient and easy to store plungers on the market.

Pros
  • Comfortable 24” handle
  • Hands-free clamshell storage canister
  • Suction element not too stiff
Cons
  • Suction cup design sometimes traps water
  • Lacks the suction force of some other plungers like the Neiko (our top pick)
  • Some are bothered by its natural rubber smell

This Good Grips toilet plunger comes with an innovative clamshell style holder that includes a drying tray so that any water left on the plunger evaporates more quickly, making it easier to clean. The holder keeps the plunger itself out of sight and is constructed of the same plastic as the handle. This storage solution is great for smaller bathrooms.

The plunger is comfortable and easy to use, thanks to a good sized 23.8-inch handle with a broad, flat top. The suction cup isn’t very stiff, which can be a benefit or a drawback. It doesn’t take much muscle to use, however it also doesn’t spring back into shape as easily as a stiffer suction cup.

 #7  ToiletTree Deluxe Freestanding Toilet Brush and Plunger Combo

Award: Best Quality

WHY WE LIKE IT: This toilet brush and plunger combo comes with a two place steel holder that keeps both brush and plunger out of sight, making it great for larger bathrooms with a “modern” design theme.

Pros
  • Brush & plunger in one
  • Hands free storage containers
  • Replaceable plunger head
Cons
  • Holder lacks ventilation for adequate drying
  • Steel brush and plunger handles can develop patina in humid bathrooms
  • Handle may be too short for some

This toilet plunger and brush combo is distinguished by its convenient included side-by-side holders. Finished in stainless steel to match the plunger and brush handle, they make these essential bathroom cleaning items unobtrusive and even contribute to a clean looking bathroom.

The plunger itself is about 18” including the handle, a bit shorter than our top choices which tend to be around 24” and this might make it harder to use for some. However, the rubber suction element provides good suction force and is even replaceable, for a longer-lasting product overall. Those with less ventilated and more humid bathrooms may want to de-rust the handles.

How we Decided

In order to narrow down the best toilet plungers on the market we looked at functionality, ease of cleaning and durability. We only included plungers that fit a range of toilet types including modern standard and older fixtures, and being able to fit elongated toilet bowl openings was considered a useful bonus. Make sure, if you have an elongated toilet, to check that the plunger you buy fits.

We looked at plungers that were at least 16” long including handles, so that you get decent leverage during use. We also considered only those with metal, painted wood or plastic handles, since untreated wood plunger handles harbor more bacteria.

While not an absolute requirement, we did give preference to toilet plungers with included holders or caddies, giving you a convenient way of storing the plunger out of sight.

Plungers Buying Guide

 

Features to Consider

  1. Suction cup shape
    The right toilet plunger for you depends in large part on what type of toilet or drain you plan to use it on. For elongated toilets, a different shape of plunger suction element is often required, since the common circular element may not get a good seal. When looking at a plunger for shower drains or bath drains on the other hand, a smaller, circular suction cup often works best.
  2. Handle
    The plunger handle has to balance leverage with compactness. You may not want a giant plunger handle taking up too much visual space in your bathroom, but a longer handle does make the job of unclogging a toilet much easer and more pleasant. Some of the best toilet plungers even have ergonomic, flat or T-shaped handles.
  3. Accessories
    Some of the plungers on our list include holders, such as the Simplehuman toilet plungers (our #4 and 5 picks) which let you hide the plunger itself in a more aesthetically appealing way. Others come with toilet bowl brushes as well, which could be a plus depending on what you’re looking for.
  4. Storage
    Many of the best plungers come with built in storage solutions, such as a hideaway caddy that keeps the rubber part out of sight, or a loop built in to the handle so you can easily hang it. If storage space is at a premium in your bathrooms, look for one that includes a storage solution that doesn’t take up too much space.

Plunger FAQs

Will these fit older toilets?

In general, all the best plungers on our list will work fine with older toilets, though for more flexibility with HE and low flow toilets, look to an accordion or “beehive” shaped plunger such as the Korky (our #3 pick)

Do the heads unscrew?

Some toilet plungers feature screw on, replaceable heads, such as the ToiletTree (our #7 pick) while others have fused on heads. Generally, this is done for simplicity of manufacturing and a balance between durability and ease of maintenance.

Also why not check out:

Ryan Mcbride

Ryan McBride is a writer based in Los Angeles. He has contributed work to magazines and sites including Gayot, Spy, Paper, Ladygunn, 3AM and the Crab Creek Review. He writes consumer reviews, essays, science and tech journalism as well as literary and art criticism.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
Close