7 Best Pie and Cake Servers in 2020

To help you find the best pie and cake server for your kitchen and dining ware collection we’ve spent over 10 hours comparing and testing the best-rated pie servers and cake servers on the market. We looked for standout durability with materials like corrosion-resistant stainless steel, good design with enough balance to handle small and large slices of cake or pie, and a cutting edge sharp enough to get through textured pie crust.

Our top pick for the best pie and cake server this time around is the Orblue Professional Pie Server. A double serrated edge lets it cut pies and cakes more cleanly while an all-stainless blade ensures a long-lasting finish. Keep reading to learn more about other high-quality pie and cake servers available for purchase.

Top 7 Best Pie and Cake Servers

 #1  Orblue Pie and Cake Server

Award: TOP PICK

WHY WE LIKE IT: This ergonomic and easy to use pie and cake server cuts through all kinds of pie crust thanks to a blade that is serrated on both sides. A well-balanced handle with soft rubber grips helps make cutting and serving perfect cake and pie slices a breeze.

Pros
  • Comfortable handle with secure rubber grip
  • Sharp blade for pie slicing
  • Serrated on both sides so works for left-handed users
Cons
  • Not large enough for some oversized cakes

This stainless steel pie and cake server is a top-rated choice and especially for left-handed home cooks it may be the best cake server on the market thanks to its great balance and its doubly serrated blade. This feature lets it cut in either orientation. The edge is sharp enough so that it works well if you’re mainly looking for the best pie slicer, too. It’s sharp enough to easily get through all types of pie crust.

10 inches long overall, this cake server and pie server, essential for a fully stocked home kitchen, goes well with a stainless steel knife set and is one of the most useful kitchen tools when it comes to cutting and serving pie, cake and even pizza. If you like serving trays, you might also be interested in our review of the best cake stand.

 #2  Fox Run Pie and Cake Server

Award: HONORABLE MENTION

WHY WE LIKE IT: This sleek, well designed stainless steel cake and pie server can also function as an excellent spatula. A single serrated edge works well for slicing a pie, and a flat edge makes it great for serving.

Pros
  • Durable, dishwasher safe all-metal construction
  • 10-inch size makes it great for large pies
  • Serrated edge sharp enough to get through pizza crust
Cons
  • Lacks a rubber handle for an ergonomic grip
  • Not the most comfortable for left handed use

This dual purpose cake server and pie server is also a dessert spatula. It’s 10 inches long and capable of cutting and serving most common pie and cake sizes. Its blade has a serrated edge on one side that performs well at cutting pie crust and pizza. On the other side, the blade is flat and optimized for lifting and serving.

While not the most comfortable for left-handed chefs, this pie slicer and spatula is versatile and very easy to clean. It is dishwasher safe and highly durable. While it lacks a left-handed serrated edge, this stainless steel pie server is nonetheless a versatile and useful kitchen implement and makes a great complement to a good cake knife and serving plate. If you’re making cupcakes, you might want to check out our guide to the best dessert cups.

 #3  HF Hoften Stainless Steel Pie and Cake Server

Award: BEST MULTIPACK

WHY WE LIKE IT: These dishwasher safe pie and cake servers come in a pack of five, making them highly convenient. They also benefit from a high quality stainless steel finish and a well shaped triangular blade for cutting and serving cake, pie, lasagna and more.

Pros
  • Sharp enough to slice pizza and turnovers
  • Comes with 5 in a set, saving time on cleaning
  • Durable stainless steel finish
Cons
  • Lacks weighted handle for balance
  • A little smaller than ideal for serving pizza and larger cakes

This pie server set includes five stainless steel pie and cake servers, making it very convenient for daily use and a good buy for busy home cooks looking for the best pie slicer set to get through a week of baking and serving.

Made from high-quality stainless steel, each pie and cake cutter in the set is 9 inches long and features a single serrated edge and a triangular shape. This makes them work well for pie slicing as well as for lifting and serving pieces of cake and other desserts. They’re fully dishwasher safe and the matte stainless finish gives them long-lasting durability. If you’re still perfecting your pie crust, our guide to the best flour sifter might help.

 #4  HST Vintage Stainless Steel 10 Inch Pie and Cake Server

Award: BEST FOR CUTTING

WHY WE LIKE IT: A sharp serrated edge and thickened, the comfortable handle gives this cake and pie server an advantage when it comes to cutting and slicing. With a 10.4 inch by 2.4-inch wide blade, it also works well for serving and transferring slices of cake and pie.

Pros
  • Loop on handle for easy storage
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Thick handle helps maintain balance when serving
Cons
  • Serrated edge only on one side, making it less convenient for left-handed cooks
  • Not as decorative as some models

This cake and pie server work well for cutting and transferring slices of your favorite dessert onto pie plates. It’s also easy to clean thanks to its all-steel construction with a corrosion resistant stainless finish. A convenient loop on the end of the handle helps make it easy to store and lets it go well with your flatware and knife set.

A sharp serrated edge and weighted handle make this the best pie cutter we’ve tested as far as how quickly it gets through different types of crust. A generous sized blade, 10.4 inches long, helps make it easy to use for serving too. For more convenient desert storage, you might also be interested in our guide to the best cookie jar.

 #5  Ksendalo Pie and Cake Server

Award: BEST MODERN DESIGN

WHY WE LIKE IT: These handsomely designed modern cake and pie servers are made from high-quality food-grade stainless steel, have a long-lasting finish, and provide good balance and support when serving cake and other desserts.

Pros
  • Well shaped triangular blade helps carry slices
  • Works for right and left-handed chefs
  • Dishwasher safe and rust-resistant
Cons
  • Blade is on the shorter side at 7.87 inches long
  • Handles not as thick or grippy as some models
  • Lacks serrated edges

These silver mirror finished pie and cake servers are a great choice if you’re looking for dessert flatware that goes well with modern decor or with a similarly designed knife set. They come in a set of two and provide convenient, well-balanced cake cutting and pie slicing. They work equally for right and left-handed chefs. Made from high-grade stainless steel, this pie and cake cutter is dishwasher safe and rust-resistant.

While the blades don’t have serrated edges as on some of the more versatile cake and pie slicers, the flat spatula type blades do work well for lifting and serving especially when it comes to softer desserts and cakes. For the rest of your cooking needs, you might also like the best automatic pot stirrer.

 #6  Wallace Hotel Pie and Cake Server Set

Award: BEST VINTAGE STYLE

WHY WE LIKE IT: Designed after the pattern of some of the best vintage pie server sets, this useful kitchen tool combo comes with a triangular pie server and cake knife made of dishwasher safe high quality stainless steel.

Pros
  • Ultra low maintenance and never needs polishing
  • High-quality stainless steel construction
  • Cake knife is the longest on our list at 12.5 inches long
Cons
  • Pie server blade lacks serrated edges

With a pattern taken from the most popular knife sets and flatware designs of European grand hotels , this dessert flatware set is elegant and great for adding some style to your cake or pie presentation. Also a highly practical kitchen tool, the included cake knife is 12.5 inches long, making it good for cutting large cakes. Designed for special occasions and everyday use as well, this set is useful for cake, pie, pizza, quiche and more.

This cake knife and pie server set is made from high quality 18/10 stainless steel, with superior corrosion resistance and a lasting finish. They’re dishwasher safe and require no polishing, making them easy to clean. The handles are well-weighted, which helps with cutting as well as with pie slicing and serving.

 #7  STONCEL Stainless Steel Pie and Cake Server

Award: BEST ON A BUDGET

WHY WE LIKE IT: This value-priced pie and cake server comes in a generous set of five and features a functional, modern design along with dishwasher safe stainless steel construction.

Pros
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Rounded triangular blade good for lifting and serving
  • Serrated cutting edge helps get through pie crusts
Cons
  • Not the easiest for left handed chefs
  • Handles not as comfortable or well-weighted as on some other pie and cake servers

A practical and convenient kitchen tool sold in a five-pack, this dual-purpose pie and cake server is nine inches long and has a 1 7/8 inch wide blade that makes it stable enough to balance pie and cake slices, which is one pie server essential feature. The blade is sharp enough to get through most types of pie crusts in a single stroke, and it’s well shaped for lifting slices out of pie tins.

The handle is not as weighted and the grip isn’t as comfortable as on some more expensive pie and cake servers, but the serrated cutting edge does make for easy pie slicing. Plus, this value-priced set comes with five individual pieces.

How We Decided

In order to bring you the best cake server and pie server on the market, we compared and tested top-rated models, looking for durability and ease of use along with good design and convenient cleaning.

We only included cake and pie slicers that were dishwasher safe. We preferred corrosion-resistant materials like stainless steel. Top-quality finishes were a bonus, and we included both gloss and matte finishes.

We only selected from among cake and pie servers that had a flat blade for balancing slices. The blades had to be at least 6 inches long by 1.5 inches wide. An ergonomic handle was considered a priority too.

Another consideration was design since the best cake server and pie cutter is likely to be a display object and part of your kitchen decor as well. We considered both vintage designs and cool, modern designs.

Finally, we gave preference to pie servers with blades that were serrated on both sides so that they’re equally convenient and comfortable for right or left-handed chefs.

Best Pie and Cake Server Buyer’s Guide

Features to Consider

  1. Blade Size
    In general, a longer, wider pie and cake server allows for larger slices, so if you typically serve large cakes, look for a blade nearly as long as the radius of the largest cake pan you use. For most home cooks, a blade that’s 10 inches long by about 2.5 inches wide is the biggest you’ll need.
  2. Finish
    For durability, look for high-quality steel construction and a stainless or corrosion-resistant finish. The level of shine is a matter of style and might depend on whether matte or high gloss finish goes better with your existing flatware and kitchen knife set.
  3. Handle
    A weighted, ergonomic handle helps avoid dropped slices by making it easier to balance the weight of the cake or pie.
  4. Serrated Edges
    If you’re looking for the best pie cutter that also works on pizza and flaky pastries, a serrated edge is helpful. For left-handed chefs, look for serrated edges on both sides.

Pie and Cake Server FAQs

What’s the difference between a cake server and a pie server?

While the functions of these two kitchen tools are often combined into one utensil, traditionally a cake server is a smooth, flat triangular blade designed for laying a piece of cake on its side on a plate, while a pie server has a small bend in the blade so that it can fit into a pie pan.

What is the best cake knife?

To find the best cake knife for you, make sure the blade is almost as long as the radius of the cake or the length of the largest slice you’ll want to cut.

What do you use to serve pie?

Ideally, you should use a pie server, which is a specially designed knife and spatula with a generally triangular blade, sometimes serrated on both sides or on one side, that fits into a pie plate and allows you to cut and lift out slices of pie.

What is a pie server called?

A pie server is variously called a dessert spatula, pie and cake server, pie cutter or crepe space.

Also why not check out:

Ryan Mcbride

Ryan McBride is a writer based in Los Angeles. He has contributed work to magazines and sites including Gayot, Spy, Paper, Ladygunn, 3AM and the Crab Creek Review. He writes consumer reviews, essays, science and tech journalism as well as literary and art criticism.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
Close