Best →

Best Mr Coffee Makers in 2022

Justin Caldwell Profile image

Written By:

Updated August 23, 2022

You might not count the Mr. Coffee brand among the best coffee makers on the market, but it has become a household name when it comes to budget coffee machines offering modern compact design, stainless steel thermal carafes, and a variety of functions. What you’ll get with the best Mr. Coffee maker is an easy-to-use brewer with features like advanced filtration, programmable settings, and automatic shut-off. And if teas or lattes are your thing, they make a model for that, too!

As the name might imply, coffee is Mr. Coffee’s specialty, and the company has been around for a long time. Their products are affordable and work sufficiently well for their intended purpose. You won’t find advanced functions or a long lasting machine with Mr. Coffee, but you will find an excellent, simple machine that is easy to care for.

Keep reading our buying guide to learn more about Mr. Coffee and their range of products.

Top Mr. Coffee Makers

 #1  Mr. Coffee SK13-RB Coffee Maker

Award: TOP PICK

WHY WE LIKE IT: This model features a durable design and decent serving size to offer a machine that works in an office breakroom or compact kitchen. Additionally, users will love the water window and removable filter basket that ensure proper operation and great flavor.

Pros
  • Simple operation
  • Water level window
  • Easy-serve carafe
Cons
  • No digital display

The Mr. Coffee SK13-RB coffee maker is a stellar pick for users who want an easy-to-use device for an office break room or small kitchen. This model features a glass carafe with clear volume markings and a heat-resistant handle for easy and safe serving. Additionally, users will love the water level window keeps so they can stay informed and never overfill the machine. While this model doesn’t feature a digital display or brew scheduling, users can start a brewing cycle with a single switch.

In addition to simple operation and serving, the Mr. Coffee SK13-RB coffee offers a stellar carafe that keeps messes to a minimum. The pointed spout ensures smooth pouring without splashes and spills, and it is completely dishwasher safe for easy cleanup. Additionally, users will love the Grab-A-Cup feature that allows them to fill their mugs midway through a brewing cycle. Lastly, this model features a warming plate to keep a fresh pot of coffee warm and ready to drink for up to two hours.

 #2  Mr. Coffee BVMC-EVX23-RB Coffee Maker

Award: HONORABLE MENTION

WHY WE LIKE IT: This brewer features a large serving capacity and an equally-sized water tank so users can have multiple servings for a busy morning or a group of friends. Additionally, users will love the convenience of the dishwasher-safe carafe and brew time schedule.

Pros
  • Impressive scheduling mode
  • Automatic shut-off feature
  • Water level window
Cons
  • Non-backlit digital display

The Mr. Coffee BVMC-EVX23-RB coffee maker is an excellent pick for users who want to pre-plan their morning brew and easily clean up after it’s done. This model features a 24-hour programming mode that lets users prepare their coffee up to a day in advance. Additionally, the clear water level window ensures that users will have enough water to accommodate their brewing cycle. While the digital display doesn’t feature a backlight, it is still clear and simple to program in minimal lighting.

In addition to a clear digital display and a convenient programming feature, the Mr. Coffee BVMC-EVX23-RB coffee maker provides strong coffee without much fuss. The water tank has a wide opening for easy filling, and the glass carafe is dishwasher safe for simple cleaning. Additionally, this model offers a two-hour hot plate so users can have multiple servings without suffering through a lukewarm mug. Lastly, users will love the Grab-A-Cup feature so they can enjoy a cup without canceling the remaining brewing cycle.

 #3  Mr. Coffee BVMC-PSTX91-RB Coffee Maker

Award: BEST FOR EARLY RISERS

WHY WE LIKE IT: This model features a stainless steel insulated carafe and a brew freshness timer so users can enjoy hot and fresh mugs during a long morning. Additionally, users will love the high brewing temperature and fast brewing speeds.

Pros
  • High brewing temperature
  • Stainless steel carafe
  • Freshness timer
Cons
  • Needs room to be functional

The Mr. Coffee BVMC-PSTX91-RB coffee maker is a compelling choice for users who want a convenient and feature-rich machine to deliver reliably fresh drinks in the morning or whenever you need one. This stainless steel model features a double-insulated carafe to keep a brew hot, and the Freshness Timer feature lets users know how long ago they brew their coffee. While this model doesn’t make for a great small coffee maker for tight spaces, the sliding filter basket is easy to operate and reinstall after filling.

In addition to an insulated carafe and a freshness timer, the Mr. Coffee BVMC-PSTX91-RB coffee maker features simple controls that deliver coffee on schedule. The clear digital display features a Brew Later function that lets users schedule their next brewing cycle. Additionally, the Auto-Pause feature lets users grab a cup of coffee before the brewing is done. Lastly, this model offers a high brewing temperature and a strong brewing mode for users who are particular about their morning brew.

 #4  Mr. Coffee 2134286 Coffee Maker

Award: BEST FOR OFFICE BREAK ROOMS

WHY WE LIKE IT: This model features a compact design and simple operation so users can have fresh mugs with a single-button operation. Additionally, this model offers a heat-resistant handle and pointed spout for easy pouring without major spills or splashes.

Pros
  • Incredibly compact
  • Simple operation
  • Easy-view water window
Cons
  • Sub-par serving capacity

The Mr. Coffee 2134286 is a superb choice for users who want to fit fresh coffee into small areas like tiny break rooms or even an office cubicle. This model offers a single switch to start the brewing process with a bright status light to let users know that the coffee maker is engaged. While this model only makes 5 cups in a brewing cycle, the glass carafe features clear ounce markings and a heat-resistant handle for safe and accurate pours.

In addition to easy serving and operation, the Mr. Coffee 2134286 coffee maker is great for offering fresh drinks to friends or enjoying a couple of servings while reading a book. Additionally, users will love the Grab-a-Cup feature so they can fill their mugs midway through a brewing cycle. The easy-view water window ensures that users won’t overfill the machine or try to brew with an empty water reservoir. Lastly, the filter basket is reusable and dishwasher safe on the top rack.

 #5  Mr. Coffee DR5-RB Coffee Maker

Award: BEST FOR PERSONAL BREWING

WHY WE LIKE IT: This compact and convenient device offers quick brewing times and mid-cycle serving so users can enjoy hot beverages, even during busy days. Thanks to the water window and clear markings on the carafe, users can accurately make and serve their drinks of choice.

Pros
  • Extremely convenient
  • Great glass carafe
  • Auto-pause for quick serving
Cons
  • Small serving capacity

The Mr. Coffee DR5-RB coffee maker is a great pick for users who want fresh coffee without needing an extensive setup or toolkit. This model offers simple brewing thanks to the removable filter basket that is easy to fill and even easier to clean. Additionally, this model features a water level window to ensure that users do not overfill the machine or run a brew cycle without enough water. While the serving capacity isn’t too big, this model is great for enjoying multiple mugs or a small meeting.

In addition to a water level window and a great filter basket, the Mr. Coffee DR5-RB coffee maker provides a user-friendly interface for easy brewing. This model features a single-button operation and a bright status light to let users know that fresh coffee is on the way. Additionally, the auto-pause feature temporarily stops a brewing cycle while a user pours themself a drink. Lastly, the stain-resistant warming plate is easy to clean, and it keeps a pot hot for up to an hour.

 #6  Mr. Coffee BVMC-SJX33GT-AM Coffee Maker

Award: BEST FOR FLAVORFUL BREWS

WHY WE LIKE IT: This brewing machine offers a user-friendly path to fresh drinks and full flavor, thanks to multiple brewing modes and integrated water filtration. Additionally, users will love the delay feature and clear digital display so they can enjoy their favorite drink on a schedule.

Pros
  • Clear digital display
  • Internal water filter
  • Great serving capacity
Cons
  • Coffee spout drips a bit

The Mr. Coffee BVMC-SJX33GT-AM coffee maker is a fantastic pick for users who want a feature-rich machine with simple brewing and a great serving capacity. This model serves up to 12 cups of fresh coffee, and the warming plate keeps a full pot hot and fresh for up to two hours. Additionally, this model features a water window so users can fill the water reservoir without risking an overflow. While the spout drips a bit after a brewing cycle, the warming plate is easy to clean and cools quickly after it shuts off.

In addition to a 12-cup serving capacity and a clear water window, the Mr. Coffee BVMC-SJXX33GT-AM coffee maker provides multiple modes so users can tailor their brew to their ideal taste. The brew strength selector lets users enjoy a bold mug, and the delay timer ensures that their fresh drink is ready when they need it. Additionally, the internal water filter removes up to 97% of chlorine from the brewing water for an improved taste.

Introduction to Mr. Coffee Makers

Founded by Vincent Marotta and Samuel Glazer in 1972, Mr. Coffee is an American brand currently owned by Newell Brands. At the time, most people used a percolator to make hot coffee, similar to the Italian Moka pot, which often made it taste burnt and bitter, and the pair wanted to create a drip coffeemaker with the goal of solving the problems that came with percolation and produce a machine that would make coffee with a more balanced flavor.

Marotta and Glazer began working on the idea for the first drip coffee maker in 1969. In September 1972, they secured the patent and released the first Mr. Coffee electric coffee maker to the public a month later. By 1973, the founder of Mr. Coffee convinced Joe DiMaggio to be a spokesman for the brand, and its popularity soared in 1974.

The original model worked a bit differently than the drip coffee makers we see today. It used gravity to pull water through a heater, flowed through the coffee grounds, and then dripped into a carafe. It wasn’t until later that these machines were designed with siphons to pull water upwards from a reservoir.

Today’s Mr. Coffee drip machines use a flash boiling chamber to heat the water quickly and then deliver it to the coffee grounds at an optimal brew temperature of 195-200 degrees. While many models come with a glass carafe, more advanced models have thermal carafes to keep the coffee hot, rather than a hot plate, which can also cause burning. Mr. Coffee also has a line of single serve Keurig alternatives, tea makers, and espresso machines.

While Mr. Coffee once produced juicers, breadmakers, and food dehydrators in the 1990s, they currently focus primarily on affordable coffee-related products.

How Mr. Coffee Compares to Other Brands

Pro 1: Mr. Coffee products are more affordable than similar machines from other manufacturers. You’ll get comparable sizes, features, and functions on a Mr. Coffee machine as you would with low-end models from other brands but for a fraction of the cost. This means you’ll find a great 5-cup coffee maker from this brand, too.

Con 1: While they work well, Mr. Coffee machines aren’t manufactured with the same high quality materials that many other brands include. They’re mostly made of BPA-free plastic, which is what makes them so affordable. However, they also won’t last as long as other, more expensive products.

Pro 2: Most Mr. Coffee machines contain dishwasher safe components, making them very easy to clean and maintain. With this type of simplicity, it’s possible to keep your machine clean and in proper working order.

Con 2: These dishwasher safe parts are plastic, which means the machine isn’t as durable as it could be. There are some people who aren’t fond of using plastic parts for extremely high temperatures because of the risk that plastic can leach chemicals.

Pro 3: Mr. Coffee machines are notorious for heating water rapidly, so they can brew up to 10 cups of coffee in under 8 minutes. Some of their machines are even faster, and the temperature is still just as optimal.

Con 3: Due to this rapid heating, Mr. Coffee machines can be quite loud. It’s about the farthest you can get from a silent machine. If you’re brewing coffee in the morning before you head out to work, you run the risk of waking the entire household.

Pro 4: Some Mr. Coffee makers have thermal carafes to keep the coffee warm. This is much better than a hot plate, which can cause a burnt coffee flavor.

Con 4: A thermal carafe is a nice feature, but Mr. Coffee makers are lacking in innovative features. They have standard functions like auto on and off, but when it comes to advanced uses, there aren’t a lot of options. Alternatively, try our list of the finest dual coffee makers with plenty of features.

Pro 5: All of Mr. Coffee’s models feature a modern aesthetic, so they’re sleek and attractive in every kitchen. If you like the way they look, you may also want to check out the best Ninja coffee maker.

Con 5: Unfortunately, even with modern flair, the plastic components still make these machines look cheaper than the competition.

Pro 6: Mr. Coffee offers a wide range of coffee makers as well as single cup brewers, tea makers, and espresso machines. Their product offering contains something for everyone, including a latte maker.

Con 6: Mr. Coffee is most well-known for their coffee machines, and it’s definitely what they’re good at. If you’re looking for specialty machines like espresso makers, you’re better off going with a brand that specializes in their performance.

Pro 7: Mr. Coffee espresso machines are a great place to start for beginners who are intimidated by the complicated functions of higher priced machines. They offer simple features and ease of use for those who love their latte every morning. They also include water reservoirs, milk reservoirs, and an easy button interface.

Con 7: Mr. Coffee doesn’t specialize in espresso machines, and your espresso won’t taste as good as it would with a higher priced machine. These machines lack consistency, but will still make it easy to brew your espresso at home.

Pro 8: Mr. Coffee does a great job of including easy controls in their programmable coffee maker lineup, giving users a familiar experience that features little to no learning curve. They also feature grab-a-cup auto pause so you can get a cup of coffee mid brewing cycle, despite the fact that the brewing time isn’t very long.

Con 8: Mr. Coffee might make it easy to use their machines, but you simply won’t get the most delicious coffee you’ve ever had. While you’ll enjoy a quick brew every morning, you won’t get the same rich-tasting coffee you would get from other machines.

Why should you buy a Mr. Coffee Maker?

Mr. Coffee makers are extremely affordable. They’re great budget options for people who want to brew an entire carafe of drip coffee or need a quick single cup in the morning. As far as budget espresso machines are concerned, you’ll also find some great options that will get you the cappuccino you want in the morning, although it won’t be quite as good as the corner coffee shop.

A Mr. Coffee machine is a good purchase for those on a budget because they work well and feature a modern aesthetic. While you may not get the advanced features that come with a higher priced coffee maker, you will get fast, convenient, consistent performance.

How Long Will a Mr. Coffee Maker Last?

The best Mr. Coffee maker will last 2-3 years, but with proper cleaning and maintenance, it may last 4-5 years. The plastic components will break down eventually, so a machine like this simply won’t last the 10-15 years that a premium coffee maker might. However, with how affordable they are, you can afford to replace it with an updated model as needed.

Mr. Coffee Warranty

Mr. Coffee offers a one-year limited warranty on material and workmanship. They guarantee that your machine will be free of defects, or else they will repair or replace it for you. The replacement will be a new or refurbished product, and if the same product is no longer available, they will replace it with a similar product.

Mr. Coffee Maker FAQs

How do I clean my machine?

You should clean your Mr. Coffee machine every 40-80 brewing cycles. While some machines have a self-cleaning cycle for your convenience, others don’t. You can put dishwasher safe parts in the dishwasher and clean other removable components by hand with a mild detergent. Run vinegar or lemon juice through a brewing cycle to clean the inside. The carafe should be cleaned after every use.

What's the warranty on Mr. Coffee espresso makers?

Mr. Coffee offers a one year limited warranty on their machines. It’s important to use your machine heavily in the beginning to ensure that anything that is going to go wrong will go wrong while it’s under warranty.

How long does it take coffee to brew?

It takes 5-10 minutes to brew a full carafe. It depends on the size of the machine and its functionality, but you can schedule your start time on machines with this capability to avoid the wait. Some machines even have pause functions that pause brewing if you remove the carafe, meaning you won’t have to wait for the entire pot to brew just to grab your first cup.

Who should buy a budget coffee maker?

If you want a decent coffee pot for less money, a Mr. Coffee machine is a good option. In fact, these are highly functional budget coffee makers that will stand the test of time. While they’re not built to last much longer than the warranty period, they can last up to 5 if they’re cared for properly. These machines are great for pre-ground coffee every morning and will brew a pot relatively quickly. They may not meet the qualifications of a coffee connoisseur, but they’re simple and efficient.

Why Buy an Espresso Machine?

If you already have a great drip coffee maker, you may be wondering if an espresso machine is worth it. Despite its learning curve, it can add a lot of variety to your coffee selection. You can make specialty beverages, steam milk, and learn a lot by experimenting. You can even make the transition to an espresso machine by making a long black or an Americano that’s similar to your drip coffee but with a richer taste. If you’re intimidated by the transition, Mr. Coffee has a great lineup of machines that are easy to use, so it’s a great place to start.
Justin Caldwell Profile image