6 Best Cookie Jars in 2020

Of the best cookie jars that we tested, the top pick is the OXO Good Grips Airtight POP Large Cookie Jar. We chose it because of its clean, clear BPA-free silicone construction, airtight lid with ingenious pop-out sealing button, generous 5-quart capacity, extreme durability, and great style.

To assemble a list of the best cookie jars available, we preferred jars with at least a 2-quart capacity, airtight-seal, and mouths wide enough for hands of all sizes. We also favored jars that were made out of high-quality, non-toxic, odor-free silicones and plastics. Bonus points were assigned for shatter-free glass or fine ceramics. Lastly, we also looked for balanced style and freshness preservation while still being affordable and easy to clean. Keep reading to see other high-quality cookie jars on the market today.

Top 6 Best Cookie Jars

 #1  OXO Good Grips Airtight POP Large Cookie Jar

Award: TOP PICK

WHY WE LIKE IT: A nearly break-proof silicone and plastic construction, a clever lid-sealing and opening button, generous capacity, and a clean, clear look make it perfect for any household.

Pros
  • Break-proof silicone and plastic construction
  • Flat back lets it sit flush against walls
  • Bottom grips prevent it from slipping on wet surfaces
Cons
  • Lacks some of the visual charm of glass and ceramic jars

The Oxo Good Grips Airtight POP Large Cookie Jar is an airtight-sealing 5 qt capacity cookie and food storage jar made from 100% BPA-free (so it’s guaranteed to be non-toxic), odor-free clear silicone and plastic, with a soft silicone sealing circle that’s removable for cleaning. The durable lid features Oxo’s unique POP button technology, which creates the airtight seal with one push and opens up the lid easily with another.
The body features a flat back so the jar can be placed flush against walls, saving valuable kitchen space, and built-in bottom grips prevent the jar from slipping on wet surfaces. It’s easily hand-washed with soap and water and unlikely to break or shatter even if dropped on tile floors.

Its multiple clever design features, extremely durable construction, and generous capacity make it the most practical, well-rounded jar on our list, and though it has slightly less homey charm than glass or ceramic jars, it’ll still look great in any kitchen, and the easy-open POP button makes this Oxo Cookie Jar especially good for seniors or people with arthritis. This will be the perfect place to store fresh cookies made on your best silicone baking mat.

 #2  Dilabee 1.5 Gallon Cookie Jar

Award: HONORABLE MENTION

WHY WE LIKE IT: Durable,semi-flexible construction made for extra large hands and designed to fit into lots of different spaces and keep snacks fresh, with an extra-wide mouth for easy refills and shipping in a 2 pack.

Pros
  • Hexagon shape allows plenty of placement options
  • Shatter-proof material
  • Extra-wide mouth for easy access refill
Cons
  • Aesthetics are somewhat plain
  • Light weight makes it less sturdy on many surfaces
  • Not dishwasher safe

The Dilabee 1.5 Gallon Cookie Jar is made of 100% chlorine-free (non-toxic and hypoallergenic) clear plastic that’s shatter-resistant and slightly flexible for maximum durability. Its 197 oz capacity and extra-wide mouth make it great for large hands and extra easy to refill. The cookie jar features a soft silicone lid with an airtight seal and its hexagonal body shape makes it stackable and offers more storage configurations than most jars on the list. It’s easily hand-washed with soap and water and, but is not dishwasher-safe.

Coming two in a pack, its stackability, high durability, flexible storage options, generous capacity, and extra-wide mouth make it the perfect option for those who need multiple options for keeping snacks fresh and readily available, even if its no-frills aesthetic favors function over style. You can put this jar on your counter next to your best onion storages/savers.

 #3  Klikel Glass Canister Cookie Jar

Award: BEST FOR LONG TERM STORAGE

WHY WE LIKE IT: Elegant style and extra sturdy, heavy-duty construction with an ultra-airtight lid that keeps snacks fresher longer than most cookie jars.

Pros
  • Ridged body for extra grip when opening
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Beautifully shaped glass and stainless steel construction
Cons
  • Less accident-proof than plastic models
  • May be too heavy for some people to handle safely

The Klikel Glass Canister Set consists of two 2 quart jars made of thick, high-quality tempered glass, with rugged stainless steel lids and non-toxic, odor-free rubber sealers for an extremely airtight seal. The glass features a ridged texture that provides exceptional grip while opening and handling, and the 11.5″ cylinder shape of the jar and lid give these jars uniform width and weight, making them extremely sturdy. The 4.25″ diameter of the jar and mouth isn’t particularly wide, which means it may not be convenient for storing as large a variety of foodstuffs as some jars, but its uniform shape and good height does make it a great option for storing dry pasta like spaghetti, in addition to cookies and some other snacks. It’s also dishwasher safe, though it’s best to place it on the upper level for normal cycles.

Its glass construction means it’s somewhat more prone to shattering and other falling damage than plastic and silicone models, and its heavier weight may be less appropriate for seniors and small children, but its sturdy, extremely elegant and modern design, superior airtight seal, ease of cleaning make it a great choice for any modern kitchen. If you’re looking for another perfect gift for someone who loves their kitchen, consider our review of the best food mill.

 #4  SevenT2 Airtight Glass Cookie Jar

Award: BEST CLASSIC DESIGN

WHY WE LIKE IT: Its clean, inviting style, labeling features, easy-to-fill large mouth, and sturdy, heavy-duty design make it perfect for a bustling kitchen that demands form and function equally.

Pros
  • Extra large, easy-access top handle
  • Includes chalkboard sticker for labeling contents
  • Dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Not guaranteed shatter-proof if dropped

The SevenT2 Airtight Glass Cookie Jar is a heavy-duty 2-quart container manufactured with 100% durable (but not shatter-proof), FDA-approved, food safe Soda Lime glass.. It features a wide mouth and a heavy glass lid with a small plastic sealing ring that forms an airtight seal. The lid is designed with an extra-large bell handle for easy access and handling, and the inside bottom of the jar is flat, not rounded-up, maximizing storage space. It’s 100% dishwasher safe but also can be washed by hand easily with soap and water.

It also comes with a chalkboard sticker for labeling contents, which combined with its clear, heavy glass construction and wide-mouthed, easy-to-fill cylindrical design makes it great not just for keeping cookies and snacks fresh and on display, but for storing flour, sugar, dry pasta, and other dry ingredients with style but practically in mind for a busy kitchen. For more of your cooking needs, you may want the best non-stick frying ball.

 #5  Lenox 827665 Butterfly Meadow Figural Gazebo Cookie Jar

Award: BEST WHIMSICAL DESIGN

WHY WE LIKE IT: Its classic, vintage farmhouse look and high-quality, durable ceramic construction offers plenty of room for treats while adding warmth and personality to your kitchen.

Pros
  • Made of chip-resistant fine porcelain
  • Easy to clean
  • Rubber sealing ring helps keep food fresh
Cons
  • Lid and rubber seal protect freshness but aren’t quite airtight

The Lenox Butterfly Meadow Figural Gazebo Cookie Jar is a 2-quart ceramic cookie jar made of 100% chip-resistant Lenox white porcelain earthenware, manufactured domestically in Lenox Kinston, North Carolina at the only remaining bone china factory in the United States. It features a gorgeous, rustic floral and butterfly design and is easily hand washable with soap and water. The heavy-duty ceramic lid features a rubber sealing ring to help keep cookies and snacks fresh, but it’s not a 100% airtight seal and thus won’t preserve foodstuffs as some other cookie jars on the market.

While it’s on the pricier side, it’s a stunning-looking, beautifully crafted piece of kitchen art that’ll add warmth and style to your home while still being a highly functional, reasonably durable, generously-sized storage option. For another addition to your kitchen arsenal, give our review of the best pizza stone a read.

 #6  Bormioli Rocco PANDORA Glass and Cookie Jar

Award: BEST FOR SUPERVISED SNACKING

WHY WE LIKE IT: A compact, ergonomic, sleek-looking container that will still keep plenty of treats fresh while being specially designed to keep kids from unauthorized access.

Pros
  • A rubber gasket keeps ingredients fresh
  • Dishwasher Safe for easy cleaning (glass component only)
  • Flat side and bottom provide more display and placement options
Cons
  • Seniors or those with arthritis may find lid difficult to open
  • Plastic lids on the fragile side

The Bormioli Rocco PANDORA Glass Cookie Jar set includes two heavy-duty, Made-In-Italy 75 ½ Oz (more than 2 quarts) glass jars with durable metallic-plastic door knob-shaped lids. The lids feature a unique rubber gasket sealing ring that creates a light suction effect, providing an airtight seal to keep cookies and other snacks fresh while making it difficult for little hands to open the jar unsupervised. The glass portion features two flat sides for placing upright or on the container’s side, giving you numerous stylish display and space-saving options, including stacking multiples or placing them flush together in rows. The glass components are 100% dishwasher safe, though the plastic lids must be hand washed with soap and water.

If you’re looking for European style and function for entertaining, kitchen dining, or for coffee table snacks but you don’t want little hands raiding the cookie jar, these are a great option that will still keep your treats fresh, and their clever two-sided design makes them great for a space-saving kitchen option as well.

How We Decided

A classic cookie jar adds warmth and appeals to any kitchen, and if you’re an avid baker or have kids in the house, it may be something of a necessity for helping to keep your kitchen clean and organized and your baked goods fresh. Nothing says “home” like the sight of a cookie jar filled with treats, but they come in a dizzying array of variety and quality, so it can be hard to make a decision that’s both practical and which suits your style.

We preferred cookie jars that could form an airtight seal to keep your cookies, baked goods, candy, and other snacks for as long as possible at any room temperature, and were rated to hold at least 2 liquid quarts by volume, since carrying weight is usually not described for these products.

We also preferred jars that were constructed of high-quality, durable, shatter-free glass, plastic, or ceramics with metal, silicone, or ceramic lids.

We liked jars that were easily handed washable with soap and water, had mouths wide enough for both adult and children’s hands to have easy access, and whose lids came off easily enough for children while still being secure.

Finally, we loved jars with beautiful, old-fashioned printed designs as well as jars with elegant, modern shapes that could fit well into any style of kitchen, and were made of guaranteed non-toxic and odor-free materials (some cheaper plastics can leave your food with odors as they age) so they wouldn’t affect the flavor of your favorite snacks.

For the purposes of our list, we left off some popular items such as Anchor Hocking jars, Disney cookie jars, and other brand-specific items like Cookie Monster cookie jars. We also left some popular specialized items like stoneware cookie jars and personalized cookie jars off our list.

Best Cookie Jars Buyer’s Guide

The Most Important Features to Consider

  1. Airtight Seal
    Cookie jars aren’t just for looks- if they’re not keeping your cookies, candy, baked goods, or other snacks fresh, they’re not much more than furniture- that’s why it’s a good idea to make sure whichever jar you decide on has an airtight seal guaranteed in the product description. Even fine ceramic jars that place style in front of function will still often feature an airtight or practically airtight lid- there’s no reason to make a sacrifice in that department- your cookies will thank you.
  2. Non-Toxic
    It may seem obvious, but with so many cheap, mass-produced home and kitchen products on the market, it’s essential that you make sure that the jar your choice is made with 100% guaranteed non-toxic material- glass and most ceramics won’t generally present an issue here, but not all plastics, rubbers, silicones, and other synthetics are necessarily safe for long-term food use, especially as they age, so check product descriptions carefully to be sure what you’re purchasing is absolutely safe for food storage.
  3. Odor-Free
    Again, generally speaking, glass and ceramics (and metal lids) won’t imbue your snacks with any odors, but if you’ve ever used cheap tupperware, you’ll know that some plastics produce a distinct odor which can affect the flavor of food- the same goes for silicone and other synthetics, and the rubber sometimes used in airtight lids- so if the jar you are looking at is constructed or partially constructed with such materials, it’s always good to look for an odor-free guarantee.
  4. Easy To Clean
    Most cookie jars (especially ceramic or glass ones) won’t be dishwasher safe- and even if they’re described as such, it’s best not to take a chance- so make sure the jar you choose is easily handed washable with soap and water- cookies, candies, and other snacks can leave a mess in a jar in no time and you’ll want to clean yours regularly to keep it from building up food odors from crumbs, chocolate, and the like.
  5. Wide-Mouthed
    You can’t always tell just by looking at a picture if the mouth of a cookie jar is wide enough to allow easy access for hands of all sizes- and it’s not just kids who like cookies- so always double-check the actual diameter of the jar’s mouth in the description and compare it with something you already have at home- you don’t want to get your cookie jar in the mail only to discover you can’t easily fit your own hand in it without knocking it off the kitchen table.

Cookie Jars FAQs

Do I need a cookie jar?

If you regularly bake or buy cookies or other easily stored baked goods- or even candy- a cookie jar is a much better way to keep them than tupperware in the pantry or fridge- it’s an inviting sight in any kitchen and can add a lot of charm and warmth to your home- especially if you have kids. Moreover, many cookie jars have air tight-sealing lids and designs that can keep your cookies, baked goods, and other snacks fresher for longer than other storage options- and still add style and charm to your kitchen while doing so.

How long will cookies stay fresh?

Cookies will stay fresh depending on both the kind of cookie jar and the kind of cookie- any cookie jar with an airtight lid will obviously keep cookies fresh and tasty longer than ones without, but on top of that, some kinds of cookies will stay fresh a lot longer than others. For example, drop cookies, sugar cookies (like your typical homemade Christmas cookies) and shortbread cookies tend to stay fresh the longest, and in a good, airtight jar can keep for up to a few weeks before getting stale, whereas cookies and baked goods with icings and sandwich cookies may only last for 3-5 days. And amongst jars that aren’t specified as having airtight lids, glass and plastic jars generally have better seals than ceramic ones, though ceramic jars are often designed favoring looks over function anyway.

What can help keep my cookies fresh for longer in a cookie jar?

Even with an airtight-sealing lid, cookies and baked goods will only last so long in a jar, but there are a few tricks that can help keep cookies fresh a little longer inside any jar. Placing a piece of wax paper over the cookies under the lid will help preserve them a little longer, as will layering the cookies or baked goods between pieces of parchment paper. You can also help keep cookies crisp by placing a piece of plain white bread in the bottom of the jar to absorb moisture. Finally, unless you’re serving them right away, you should always let your cookies and baked goods cool off completely before storing them, especially in any airtight container- otherwise you risk them getting soggy and reduce their freshness window considerably.

What’s the best cookie jar?

The best cookie jar that we found is the OXO Good Grips Airtight POP large cookie jar, which tops our list and is a great-looking clear and white silicone jar with an airtight lid and a 5 quart capacity. It’s extremely durable and won’t break even if dropped off high shelves, and it’s a great value.

Also why not check out:

Jed Smith

I'm a musician and recording engineer and live in Queens. I have a cat. Her name is Elsa. I love to write about consumer tech and musical instruments.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
Close