7 Best Cookie Cutter Sets in 2020

To help you find the best cookie cutter set for your home or commercial baking needs, we have tried out a multitude of top products, testing them for durability, preferring cutters made from high-grade components such as stainless steel. We also liked cookie cutter sets that were available in and fun and unique shape options and those that arrived with plenty of cutters in one shipment.

The best cookie cutter set we tried was easily the Wilton Cookie Cutters Set. This highly versatile set ships with 101 cutters in a variety of shapes to suit birthdays, holidays, and more. Each cutter is made from food-grade plastic and can easily be cleaned in the dishwasher. Keep reading to learn more about other high-quality cookie cutter sets available for purchase.

Top 7 Best Cookie Cutter Sets

 #1  Wilton Cookie Cutter Set

Award: TOP PICK

WHY WE LIKE IT: Amazingly versatile cookie cutter set, shipping with 101 pieces in designs to suit birthdays, nearly every holiday and spelling out messages, as the entire alphabet is included.

Pros
  • Ships with over 100 units in variety of designs
  • Dishwasher safe
  • BPA-free
Cons
  • Plastic blade not as sharp as stainless steel models
  • There are larger cutters on the market
These Wilton cookie cutters receive stellar cookie cutter reviews due to their extreme versatility, as this set ships with 101 pieces in a wide variety of styles and designs. These unique cookie cutters can make birthday-themed cookies, cookies for nearly holiday and even spell out entire messages, thanks to geometric shaped cutters and the entire alphabet being included. We also loved that this Wilton 101-piece set is both dishwasher safe and BPA-free.

These are plastic cookie cutters, however, and the blades along the bottom are not as sharp as those found with stainless steel cutters, though we found them to be plenty serviceable. Additionally, some of the included cutters are on the smaller side and may not be the right choice if you are looking to make larger-than-average cookies. These cookies would still probably fit in your best cookie jar, though.

 #2  Ann Clark Cookie Cutter Set

Award: HONORABLE MENTION

WHY WE LIKE IT: Great Christmas-themed set that is perfect for making sugar cookies, manufactured in the USA with food-grade steel and featuring ultra-sharp blades.

Pros
  • Made with food-grade steel
  • Blades are sharp enough to easily cut dough
  • Made in the USA
Cons
  • Christmas-themed cookies only
  • Cannot be cleaned in dishwasher

This Ann Clark Cookie Cutter Set is perfect for all of your Christmas baking needs, as this set features a bevy of holiday-themed shapes and designs, including reindeer, candy canes and more. These stainless steel cookie cutters are made from food-grade components and feature ultra-sharp blades that easily cut through cookie dough, up to one inch thick. We also loved that these cutters are made in the USA and that this is a cutter set with a recipe book included.

Though these are certainly high-quality cookie cutters, the designs are for the holiday season only and will likely not be useful for birthdays or occasions such as baby showers. Also, these cutters cannot be placed in the dishwasher and are for hand washing only. You might also want to use the best silicone baking mat when you’re cooking in your home.

 #3  Fox Run 3683 Dog Bone Cookie Cutter Set

Award: BEST FOR PETS TREATS

WHY WE LIKE IT: Perfect for making dog treats, as these food-grade stainless steel cutters arrive in different-sized bone shapes and ship in a collectible storage tin.

Pros
  • Nice variety of sizes
  • Made from high-grade stainless steel
  • Comes with collectible storage tin
Cons
  • Only 1 design
  • Ships with 3 cutters

This Fox Run 3683 Dog Bone Cookie Cutter Set is perfect for making dog biscuits and other pet treats, as they arrive in a unique and fun dog bone shape. There are a variety of sizes on offer, suiting the tastes of nearly any-sized dog or person, and each cutter is made from food-grade stainless steel. We also loved that this set shipped with a collectible storage tin, which we found to be both attractive and handy.

Though the dog-bone design is certainly unique and perfect for making treats, it is the only design that ships with this cookie cutter set, limiting versatility. Additionally, this cookie cutter set only ships with three cutters, whereas some sets ship with many more. If you also want to make cupcakes, you should buy the best reusable baking cups.

 #4  Homy Feel Round Cookie Cutter Set

Award: BEST QUALITY

WHY WE LIKE IT: Set includes 12 high-quality circular cutters each made from commercial grade 304 stainless steel, making them rust-proof, dishwasher-safe and oven-safe up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

Pros
  • Rust-proof and oven-safe up to 500 F
  • Made from food-grade stainless steel
  • Rolled top edges to protect fingers as you cut
Cons
  • Circles only, though does have many sizes

This Homy Feel Round Cookie Cutter Set ships with 12 circular cutters, each featuring a top notch design that makes them excel in home use or as professional cookie cutters. Each cutter is made from commercial grade 304 stainless steel, meaning they are rust-proof, dishwasher-safe and oven-safe up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit (that means broiler safe.) We also loved the rolled top edges, which helps protect fingers from accidental damage as you go about the cookie cutting process.

Though these are the best round cookie cutters that we tried, the only shape available is a circle, which limits the versatility on offer. Also, there are a wide variety of sizes here, from a one-inch diameter to over four inches in diameter, which we appreciated. You’ll use this cookie cutter set so much, that it will soon become part of your best cookware.

 #5  Winblo Cookie Cutter Set

Award: MOST DURABLE

WHY WE LIKE IT: Extremely durable cookie cutter set, made from food-grade aluminum that is certified to last for years, and coming with 40 individually-designed cutters, for versatility.

Pros
  • Dozens of unique designs
  • Made from food-grade aluminum
  • Blades sharp enough to cut through cheese, veggies and other food items
Cons
  • Not for the dishwasher
  • Does not ship with storage tin

This Winblo 40-piece cookie cutter set is made from ultra-durable and food-grade aluminum alloy, so each cutter should retain its shape and usefulness for years to come. We loved that this set ships with 40 uniquely designed pieces to suit a wide variety of holidays, including birthdays, and some that come in general fun shapes, such as animals, hearts and houses. The blades are also sharp enough for all cookie dough types and excel at cutting through cheese and some vegetables.

Though the food-grade aluminum alloy that is featured with this set is of a high-quality, the company recommends hand washing these cutters instead of placing them in the dishwasher. Additionally, this cookie cutter set does not ship with a storage tin, so a cutter could become lost if you aren’t careful. If you really want to upgrade your kitchen, check out the best gas cooktop too.

 #6  Topenca Supplies Square Cookie Cutter Set

Award: BEST ON A BUDGET

WHY WE LIKE IT: Budget-friendly cookie cutter set with plenty of high end features, including an innovative dual-sided design, allowing for scalloped-edged and straight-edged cookies.

Pros
  • Innovative dual-sided design
  • Comes in handy storage tin
  • Good variety of size options
Cons
  • Blades not as sharp as steel cutters
  • 5 piece set

This Topenca Supplies Square Cookie Cutter Set comes in at a budget-friendly price point while offering features in line with higher priced competitors, with an innovative dual-sided design that allows for the cutting of scalloped-edged and straight-edged cookies. We also loved the size options here, as this set can make cookies from one inch in diameter to nearly four inches in diameter. The handy storage tin that ships with the set is also incredibly useful, making it difficult to lose a cutter or two.

Though the blades here are sharp enough for most doughs that we tested these cutters with, this is a plastic set and not quite as sharp as a steel cookie cutter. Also, this is a five-piece cookie cutter set, which is smaller than many sets available for purchase.

 #7  Ultra Cuisine Round Cookie Cutter Set

Award: BEST MULTI-USE

WHY WE LIKE IT: Versatile set of 11 circular cutters that are great for cookies, but also excel with shaping biscuits, doughnuts, scones and an assortment of other pastries.

Pros
  • Rust-proof, with welded seams and polished sides
  • Ships with 3 stencils for decorating
  • Rolled tops for hand safety
Cons
  • Circles are only shapes available
  • Storage tin is not stainless steel

This Ultra Cuisine Round Cookie Cutter Set is extremely versatile and is perfect for making cookies, in addition to forming out other types of pastries, including doughnuts, scones, bagels and biscuits. We loved the high-quality stainless steel design, which features welded seams and polished sides, in addition to being rust-proof. The rolled tops were also handy, as they help to protect fingers as you go about cutting.

Though the cutters in this set are available in a wide variety of diameters, from one inch to nearly four inches around, the only shape available is a circle. Additionally, the included storage tin is not made from stainless steel, so don’t put these cutters away wet, or the tin itself can rust.

How We Decided

To help narrow down to the above list, we focused primarily on efficient and easy-to-use cookie cutters, preferring cookie cutters that easily cut through most dough types and those with blades sharp enough to handle other types of pastries, including doughnuts, bagels, scones, and biscuits, among others. We also loved cookie cutters with rounded edges on the top, so as to protect fingers during use.

As far sizes go, we liked cookie cutter sets that allowed for multiple cookie sizes, ranging from around one inch in diameter to four inches in diameter. We also admired sets that came in with plenty of different designs and shapes, from your typical circular cookie design to unique and outlandish designs that are perfect for birthdays and a wide assortment of holidays.

We liked cookie cutters made from stainless steel, aluminum alloy, and food-grade plastic, as each manufacturing component offered ease-of-use. Cookie cutters that could be thrown in the dishwasher, for easy cleaning, were also preferred, as were cutters that were rust-proof and oven-safe. Finally, we liked cookie cutter sets that arrived in storage tins, to help keep all of the cutters together.

Best Cookie Cutter Set Buyer’s Guide

The Most Important Features to Consider

  1. Shape and Size
    You are likely going to want to keep an eye on what shapes and sizes are available with the cookie-cutter sets you are thinking of purchasing. Many cookie cutter sets come in a wide variety of shapes to suit holidays, birthdays and general use. Some sets offer a wide range of diameter choices, offering many sizes of cookies, typically ranging from one inch in diameter to around four inches in diameter.
  2. Durable Components
    Look for cookie cutters made from high-quality and food-grade components. To that end, many sets feature cutters made from durable stainless steel, aluminum alloy or even plastic, all of which are certified to be food-grade. However, the type of components on offer can affect how you clean the cutters, as only stainless steel is usable in the dishwasher. Additionally, plastic and aluminum alloy may not be oven safe. Be sure to read the fine print.
  3. Additional Uses
    Many cookie cutters and biscuit cutters can be used to shape food items above and beyond just cookies. Some cutters can be used to form doughnuts, bagels, scones, and other pastries, while others can easily cut through cheese, vegetables or act as a holder for eggs, so as to keep them in place as they cook. You are sure to be surprised at just how versatile some cookie-cutter sets can be, thanks to their sharp edges.

Cookie Cutter Set FAQs

Are metal or plastic cookie cutters better?

In general, metal cookie cutters, such as those made from stainless steel, offer sharper blades, which can cut through dough easily. Stainless steel cutters can also typically be placed in the dishwasher for easy cleaning. Plastic cutters, however, are cheaper to produce and often come in large multipacks with plenty of size and design options.

Will cookie cutters melt in the oven?

This depends on the materials used in the manufacture of the cookie cutters. Plastic cookie cutters should not be placed in the oven, and can melt, but some stainless steel cutters are perfectly fine to roast in the oven. Make sure to read the directions and check out the maximum temperatures the cookie cutters can withstand.

Can you cook eggs in a cookie cutter?

Absolutely, so long as they are made from durable components, such as stainless steel. If your cookie cutter can withstand extreme heat, then you can place an egg in it and cook it in the cutter. This allows for unique egg shapes.

Are metal cookie cutters oven safe?

Make sure to read the directions first, but most metal cookie cutters should be okay in the oven. This way you can make cookies and other pastries right in the cutters themselves, helping them to retain their shape.

Also why not check out:

Lawrence Bonk

Lawrence Bonk is a copywriter with a decade of experience in the tech space, with columns appearing in Engadget, Huffington Post and CBS, among others. He has a cat named Cinnamon.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
Close