- 1 Top 7 The Best Comforter Set Compared
- 1.1 #1 Utopia Bedding Printed Comforter Set with 2 Pillow Shams – Top Pick
- 1.2 #2 AmazonBasics 7-Piece Light-Weight Microfiber Bed-In-A-Bag Comforter Bedding Set – Honorable Mention
- 1.3 #3 Chezmoi Collection 3-Piece Down Alternative Comforter Set – Best for Solid Colors
- 1.4 #4 Downluxe Lightweight 3-Piece Comforter Set – Best Style
- 1.5 #5 Comfy Bedding Frame Jacquard Microfiber Queen 5-piece Comforter Set – Best for All Seasons
- 1.6 #6 Wake In Cloud – Floral Comforter Set – Best Cotton
- 1.7 #7 Bedsure 8-Piece Bed-in-A-Bag Comforter Set – Best Value
- 1.8 How We Decided
- 2 Comforter Set Buying Guide
We selected the best comforter set by narrowing down our criteria to focus on the comforter filling, weight, construction, bedding accessories, and design. One of the most important factors is to find a comforter set that fits your bed. But they also come in a range of designs which can help you revamp a bedroom without the expense of a full redecorating project. You’ll want to look for a comforter set that features a warm yet breathable comforter, that’s easy to care for and comes with matching bedding.
For these reasons, we selected the Utopia Bedding Printed Comforter Set with Two Pillow Shams as our top pick. It was also our best budget pick because of the extremely affordable price. This down alternative comforter set is available in two prints and comes with two matching pillow shams. A sturdy yet soft microfiber exterior is designed to resist ripping and tearing and is machine washable. Best of all, the comforter’s hypoallergenic silicone fill will be ideal for people with allergies. And if you have sciatica, check out the best mattress for sciatica.
Top 7 The Best Comforter Set Compared
#1 Utopia Bedding Printed Comforter Set with 2 Pillow Shams – Top PickWHY WE LIKE IT: A modern print queen-sized down alternative comforter set that features a bold design with matching pillow shams. The machine-washable brushed microfiber exterior offers a soft texture while the construction resists ripping or tearing, and a silicone filling reduces the chance of allergens.
If you’re just starting out with your first place, or are thinking about updating that spare bedroom, the Utopia Bedding Printed Comforter Set is a great starter option. This three-piece set comes with a comforter and two matching pillow shams. You’ll like that this down alternative filling is designed with warmth and comfort in mind.
The fabric is a brushed microfiber that ensures it’ll resist ripping or tearing. Most importantly, all of the items in this comforter set can be machine washed and tumble dried — making this an easy item to maintain. Choose from two modern mosaic prints. Look for this one at the Best Online Mattress Stores.
#2 AmazonBasics 7-Piece Light-Weight Microfiber Bed-In-A-Bag Comforter Bedding Set – Honorable MentionWHY WE LIKE IT: A complete bedroom design in one seven-piece from AmazonBasics that centers around a lightweight down alternative machine washable comforter. The set comes with a comforter, flat sheet, fitted sheet, two pillow shams, and two queen pillowcases.
Who doesn’t love a “bed-in-a-bag”? Bed-in-a-bag concepts allow you to buy everything you need for your bedding design in one convenient space. This AmazonBasics seven-piece set features everything you need to create a cohesive look in your bedroom. The set comes complete with a comforter, flat and fitted sheet, two pillow shams and two queen-sized pillowcases.
Choose from 15 designs with this microfiber collection for a luxe and soft feel that you’ll enjoy night after night. The comforter is also filled with 100% polyester for a warm yet lightweight construction. The set is also machine washable, making it easy to maintain. Speaking of comfort, read up on our Puffy Lux Mattress Review: 60+ Night Review.
#3 Chezmoi Collection 3-Piece Down Alternative Comforter Set – Best for Solid ColorsWHY WE LIKE IT: A simple three-piece down alternative comforter set that’s perfect for building out your bedroom decor. Choose from 12 colors, the set comes with a polyester fill comforter and two pillow shams.
Some people love patterns and bold designs, but others prefer the simplicity of a solid hue. If you prefer a streamlined look, the Chezmoi Collection 3-Piece Comforter Set is the perfect way to build out a bedroom design without committing to a bold pattern. Available in 12 colors, this collection features a comforter and two matching pillow shams. It is also available in 5 different sizes, the Twin Full Queen King and King Carlifornia size.
This machine-washable set is made from microfiber polyester for a soft, yet strong feel. You’ll also like that the comforter features sturdy box stitching to keep the polyester fill in place even after you wash it. It’s also great that the set includes two shams and pillow cases. If you liked our Audew Upgraded Queen Size Air Mattress Review, this goes great with that bed.
#4 Downluxe Lightweight 3-Piece Comforter Set – Best StyleWHY WE LIKE IT: A reversible three-piece comforter set that features an all-season diamond stitching, down alternative comforter, and two matching pillow shams. Choose from 18 machine washable sets that include solid colors to patterns.
Choice, choice, and more choice is why this Downluxe Lightweight 3-Piece Comforter Set makes our list. In addition to the down alternative comforter and two matching pillow shams, you’ll love that the comforters are reversible — adding to the versatility of your room’s decor. Choose from 18 styles that include solid hues or colorful patterns.
The bedding duvet cover features diamond stitching which helps to keep the allergy-friendly polyester fill in place. And the washing machine friendly construction makes it easy to clean and care for these sets. Read our Casper Essential review while you are thinking about comforters.
#5 Comfy Bedding Frame Jacquard Microfiber Queen 5-piece Comforter Set – Best for All SeasonsWHY WE LIKE IT: An all-season down alternative comforter set with a luxe jacquard microfiber tonal pattern. The microfiber sheet set comes with a comforter, two standard pillowcases, one rectangular decorative pillow, and one square decorative pillow.
If you prefer a more luxe effect for your bedding, the Comfy Bedding Frame Jacquard Microfiber Five-Piece Comforter Set is an ideal choice. In addition to the down alternative comforter, you also get two standard pillowcases, one rectangular and one square decorative pillow. The microfiber exterior and filling are designed to be hypoallergenic as well as soft.
You’ll also appreciate that all the items are machine washable. And best of all, the comforter is designed for year-round use so you won’t sweat in the summer or freeze in the winter. Choose from six tonal pattern designs. It also comes in different sizes such as Full Queen King or California King. You will love having these bedroom essentials in your life.
#6 Wake In Cloud – Floral Comforter Set – Best CottonWHY WE LIKE IT: A bold selection of floral styles makes this three-piece comforter set a must-have option. The 100 percent cotton construction includes a comforter and two pillow shams with a hypoallergenic microfiber comforter fill.
Bold floral prints are all the rage these days. And with the Wake In Cloud Floral Comforter Set you can choose from five unique styles that will help to bring your bedroom to life. This three-piece set comes with a comforter and two matching pillow shams. The 100% cotton is soft to the touch and durable.
The comforter has a soft yet warm microfiber fill that’s machine washable. You’ll like that the print is fade resistant and that the comforter is breathable and hypoallergenic.
#7 Bedsure 8-Piece Bed-in-A-Bag Comforter Set – Best ValueWHY WE LIKE IT: Imagine getting everything you need to complete your bedroom decor. This bed in a bag set features eight machine-washable pieces — a down alternative reversible comforter, a flat and fitted sheet, two pillow shams, two pillowcases, and one bed skirt — for a modest price.
Some people prefer more than a simple comforter and pillowcase combination. If you want a bed that looks completely coordinated, this Bedsure 8-Piece Bed-in-A-Bag Comforter Set should be at the top of your list. We’ve chosen it for our Best Value selection because of the total number of items you receive for the modest price. This set comes with a reversible down alternative comforter, a flat and fitted sheet, two pillow shams, two pillowcases, and a matching bed skirt to pull the entire look together.
You’ll like that of the four available styles, each features a hand-drawn pattern in a vivid hue. The microfiber fabric is soft to the touch but designed to stand up to extended use and machine washing. The comforter is also lightweight yet breathable so that you’ll never wake up sweaty in the middle of the night.
How We Decided
One of the easiest ways to update your bedroom is by changing the bedding. And the most cost-effective option is a comforter set. There are plenty of options on the market so we narrowed down the field by focusing on a few important factors. Once you adjust for picking the right comforter size and a design that appeals to you, you need to consider the comforter’s filling, construction, thickness, additional bedding accessories, and price.
We began by looking at the comforter filling. Within reasonable price ranges, your most popular filling options will be polyester. Most of the products we reviewed had comforters with a microfiber polyester fill. This type of fill offers a reasonable level of warmth but is also designed with machine washing in mind. Likewise, most of the brands on our list used microfiber for the comforter’s shell and the additional bedding accessories.
Next, we looked at the comforter construction. No one wants to deal with a comforter that gets lumpy from the washing machine. So, we prioritized comforters that featured additional stitching to keep fill or batting from shifting through everyday use or in the wash. Thickness was another factor that is going to be important for you based on your body temperature and whether you live in a warm or cold climate. While there were a few brands that specified an all-season comforter, most featured a plush yet somewhat thinner fill that is designed for use in temperate weather.
If you’re buying a comforter set, you’re hoping to create a complete look without having to shop all over town. At a minimum, a comforter set should include matching pillowcases also known as shams. Regardless of your budget, you can find a set with this baseline collection. But if you’re willing to do a bit more searching, you can find comforter sets that include as many as eight or more pieces. This can include items like bed skirts, pillows, additional pillow covers, as well as fitted and flat sheets.
And finally, we considered the price. People tend to swap out comforter sets far more frequently than something like a mattress. So, we looked for wallet-friendly options that wouldn’t break the bank. Like we mentioned earlier, you can find a quality comforter set that comes with matching pillowcases at extremely modest prices. So we kept our reviews limited to comforter sets that didn’t exceed $100.
Comforter Set Buying Guide
The Most Important Features to Consider
- Comforter Size
This is an obvious one, but just like when you buy sheets for your bed, you select the types of bedding
and size based on the length and width of your bed. Standard options include Twin size, Full, Full/Queen, Queen, and King sizes. But you can also find specialty sizes such as Twin XL, Oversized Queen size bed comforter set or Oversized King.
- Comforter Filling
The bedding comforter filling is going to be one of the most important features that you need to consider. Typically, the filling can be placed into two categories — down and down alternative. Down is made from feathers and tends to be the warmest and most super soft option for your comforter. A goose down comforter is considered to be the most luxurious comforter by many. We are talking elegant comfort. But some people are allergic to down feathers or don’t like that the feather’s quills can poke through the encasement. If this sounds like you, then down alternative filling that is typically made from polyester is a smarter option. Note though that most comforter sets feature polyester filling because it’s a far more affordable option as opposed to down fill. And just to make sure the comforter set is right for you, some come with a 30-day risk-free trial.
- Comforter Weight/Thickness
Since most duvet cover set ideas feature down alternative comforters, these are typically going to be heavier comforters than down-filled versions. However, you should still consider this feature as it’s going to directly impact how warm or cool you’ll feel when you use the comforter. Heavier or thicker down alternative comforters have more filling and are designed for cooler regions or people who prefer to be warmer when they sleep. In contrast, a lighter or thinner down alternative comforter is ideal for warmer regions or people who want to stay cool while they sleep.
- Comforter Construction
Nothing’s worse than washing a comforter and finding that all of the fill has shifted into weird lumps. To avoid this, look for stitching that helps to keep the filling in place. This can range include channel stitching, baffle boxes (typically only seen on down-filled comforters) and quilt stitching.
- Thread Count
Thread count refers to the total number of threads woven into each inch of fabric on a comforter’s shell. Just like with sheets, this number can vary and the higher the number, the softer your comforter will feel and higher thread count comforters will hold up better in the long term.
- Bedding Accessories
Comforter sets or a bedinabag set typically comes with a selection of standard accessories such as pillowcases, decorative pillows, bed skirts, and in some cases sheets for a fully coordinated bed. Depending on your budget, you can also find comforter sets that feature additional accessories such as matching lamp shades or curtains.
Along with accessories, comforter sets are an easy way to update the look of your room without fully redecorating a room. This is going to be a personal choice based on your design taste and color preferences, but there are countless options from solid colors to patterns, abstract designs, and artistic recreations. The choice is yours.
Comforter Set FAQs
Why aren’t down comforter sets more common?
Down is a more expensive comforter filling. As compared to down alternatives like polyester or even wool, down is a warmer yet more lightweight option. But down comforters usually require more construction features such as baffle boxes or gussets to keep the down in place and create that luxe thickness. When taking all of these factors into account, it’s rare to find down comforter sets.
Do I need a duvet cover if I have a comforter set?
You don’t need one since the comforter already features a design or color scheme of some type. Duvet covers are usually used with down comforters to help protect them from getting dirty. Down comforters can be difficult to wash — which is why a duvet cover is a practical solution. But a comforter from a comforter set can be used with a duvet if you want to quickly change the look of a room, or prefer to sleep without a top sheet.
Which is more economical, buying all of my bedding separately or with a comforter set?
If you’re the type who prefers for their bedding to be fully coordinated, it will usually be cheaper to buy a comforter set versus buying the various included items separately. This is especially true if, in addition to a comforter or sheet set and pillow covers, you also want a bed skirt or decorative pillows to complete the look with your cover set.
I’m most concerned about comforter weight and fill, as well as thread count. Is a comforter set my best option?
Comforter sets are designed with economics in mind. While these sets can feature warm comforters with a median range filling and thread count, you may find that higher thread counts or premium fillings aren’t as readily available in a set. If your heart is set on a down-filled comforter, or the highest thread count you can find, you will be better served to buy your bedding individually.
Also why not check out:
- Audew Upgraded Queen Size Air Mattress Review
- Bear Mattress Review
- Best Cushion Covers (16 x 16) in 2020 (May Reviews)
- Best Mattress for Sciatica
- Best Pillow for Sleeping
- Best Twin Futon in 2020 (May Reviews)
- Casper Essential Mattress Review: A 2 Month Sleep Study
- Casper Mattress Review
- Casper Mattress Review: Is It Coitus Compatible?
- Eve Mattress Review
- Leesa Sapira Mattress Review
- Leesa Mattress Review
- Novosbed Review
- PangeaBed Mattress Review
- Puffy Lux Mattress Review: 60+ Night Review
- Sealy Cocoon Mattress Review