7 Best Baking Cup Liners in 2020

The best baking cup liners you can buy today are easily the Wilton Baking Cup Liners. These high-grade baking cup liners come in unique and kid-friendly designs that really pop, in addition to being made from food-grade and fully recyclable components.

To help you find the best baking cup liners, such as cupcake liners, we have tried out a multitude of top models, testing to ensure they are manufactured using food-grade materials that easily integrate with cupcake baking, muffin making and other assorted baked goods. We also loved baking cup liners that could withstand ultra-hot temperatures, often via aluminum or heavy paper components. Keep reading to learn more about other high-quality baking cup liners available for purchase.

Top 7 Best Baking Cup Liners

 #1  Wilton Baking Cup Liners

Award: TOP PICK

WHY WE LIKE IT: The best cupcake liners that won’t stick, featuring a bevy of unique kid-friendly design options and being made from recyclable paper and soy-based dye, all while coming in at a budget-friendly price point.

Pros
  • Best on a budget
  • Made from recyclable soy-based dye
  • Features unique kid-friendly designs
Cons
  • Made from heavy paper, and not aluminum foil
  • Not quite reusable

These Wilton cupcake liners are fantastic baking cups, thanks to coming in a variety of kid-friendly colors and patterns and being manufactured to avoid sticking after you have finished the baking process. We also loved this is a budget-friendly item, yet still shipping with 150 baking cup liners that are each made from recyclable materials, including high-grade paper and soy-based dye.

Though these baking cup liners are designed so cupcakes and muffins do not stick after baking, we did find that they were fragile enough to be single-use only. Additionally, these baking cup liners are made from heavy paper and not aluminum foil, which somewhat impacts their durability and temperature rating. If you want to avoid the mess while you’re baking, you should also look at our guide to the best silicone baking mat.

 #2  Mr. Miracle Standard Size Baking Cup Liners

Award: HONORABLE MENTION

WHY WE LIKE IT: Extremely large multipack that ships with hundreds of baking cup liners, each featuring a greaseproof design and a large enough diameter for bigger-than-average cupcakes and muffins.

Pros
  • Ships with hundreds in 1 large multipack
  • Greaseproof design
  • 4.5” size is roomy enough for big cupcakes and muffins
Cons
  • Can occasionally stick to other liners before using
  • White paper baking cups only

These Mr. Miracle Standard Size Baking Cup Liners ship in an ultra-large multipack of 500 disposable liners, which is enough to adequately cater to the largest of events. We loved the non-stick design, making these some of the best greaseproof cupcake liners around, that truly excel after you spray a tiny bit of cooking oil onto the surface. The large 4.5-inch size, diameter, was also appreciated as we found that this allowed for the baking of large cupcakes and muffins.

Though Mr. Miracle does ship 500 cupcake holders in this multipack, which is astounding, we did find that they could stick together before use, as they were tightly packed together. Also, there is only one color available here, as these are white cupcake liners. When you’re done baking, check out the best cake decorating tools to bring your cupcakes to the next level.

 #3  Gifbera Standard Silver Foil Baking Cup Liners

Award: BEST FOR BIRTHDAYS

WHY WE LIKE IT: Baking cup liners available in an astounding 10 color choices, to suit nearly any taste, with an eco-friendly and food grade foil design and a large 2” diameter to make sizable cupcakes and muffins.

Pros
  • Great color variety & 2” diameter
  • Made from eco-friendly and food grade foil
  • Plastic container keeps the cups’ shape for easy removal
Cons
  • Not for the microwave
  • Not waterproof

These Gifbera Standard Silver Foil Baking Cup Liners are made from eco-friendly and food grade silver foil, which can easily stand up to high baking temperatures. We also loved the large 2-inch2 inch diameter and the fact that they are available for purchase in ten different color options, suiting nearly any taste. The plastic container that shipped with the baking cup liners was also of a high quality, adhering to the shape of the cups for easy storage and removal.

Though these baking cup liners excel in the oven at ultra-high temperatures, they cannot be placed in the microwave, as the foil materials could catch fire. Additionally, these baking cup liners are not waterproof, so be wary about adding berries and other moisture-heavy ingredients to your baked goods. If you want to add to your collection of baking items, check out our guide to the best flour sifter too.

 #4  Chambers Bay Baking Company Baking Cup Liners

Award: BEST ECO-FRIENDLY

WHY WE LIKE IT: Extra-large design, approaching 3” in diameter, which are perfect for making large muffins for breakfast, with each reusable baking cup liner offering functionality in the dishwasher, oven, microwave and the freezer.

Pros
  • Dishwasher, oven, microwave and freezer safe
  • Reusable design
  • BPA, phthalate, and lead free
Cons
  • Only ships with 13 liners
  • 6 color choices

These Chambers Bay Baking Company Baking Cup Liners are jumbo sized, nearly three inches in diameter, and are the perfect size for making extra-large cupcakes or breakfast muffins. We also loved the eco-friendly and safe materials used in the manufacture, which are BPA, phthalate and lead free. These are reusable baking cup liners, so you can expect them to last for years to come.

Though these are high-grade baking cup liners, this multipack only ships with 13 units, which is significantly less than other packs available for purchase. Also, there are only six color choices, which is on the lower end. For when you’re making cookies, you should also read our guide to the best cookie cutters.

 #5  MontoPack Mini Baking Cup Liners

Award: BEST JUNIOR-SIZED

WHY WE LIKE IT: 300 pack of small-sized baking cup liners, which are perfect for mini cupcakes, peanut butter cups and assorted candies, with a non-toxic and food grade formulation.

Pros
  • Free of odors or toxic materials
  • Ships with 300 liners in 7 colors
  • Great for peanut butter cups and other candies
Cons
  • Disposable design and no reusable
  • Oven safe, but only up to 425 F

If you are wondering what size cupcake liners do bakeries use to create mini cupcakes and muffins, then this 300 pack of mini muffin tins by MontoPack will be the answer. Their teensy 1.15 inch diameter are perfect for mini cupcakes, mini muffins and even peanut butter cups and assorted candies. We also loved the seven bright colors on offer and the safe and non-toxic materials used during manufacture, as these baking cup liners have met the standards set forth by several safety organizations.

Though this multipack does ship with 300 baking cup liners in a variety of seven bright colors, they are a disposable design and are not reusable after initial use. Additionally, they are somewhat fragile, temperature-wise, and cannot be placed in ovens exceeding 425 degrees Fahrenheit. If you love to bake, you should also read our guide to the best KitchenAid mixer.

 #6  AmazonBasics Reusable Baking Cup Liners

Award: HIGHEST TEMPERATURE RESISTANCE

WHY WE LIKE IT: Disposable muffin liners that can withstand temperatures up to 500 F, meaning they can be placed underneath the broiler, in addition to being safe for the microwave, the freezer, and the dishwasher, for the purposes of cleanup.

Pros
  • Sized to fit in any standard muffin pan
  • Freezer, microwave, and dishwasher safe
  • No cooking oil needed, like baked goods pop right out
Cons
  • Only ships with 12
  • Smell like silicone upon opening, but fades after wash

These AmazonBasics Reusable Baking Cup Liners are made from food-grade silicone and are designed to withstand massive temperatures, up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, in addition to being sturdy enough for the microwave, the freezer, and the dishwasher, so they are easy to clean. We also loved the standard size, which easily fit in any average muffin or cupcake pan, and the fact that these baking cup liners are greaseproof, so you don’t need to add additional oil.

These baking cup liners ship in a pack of 12, which is just enough to fill one muffin tray, so we’d advise caution when handing them out to children, so as to make sure some don’t become lost. Also, we found that these baking cup liners smelled strongly of silicone upon opening, but that odor faded once we ran them through the dishwasher.

 #7  Freshware Silicone Baking Cup Liners

Award: BEST QUALITY

WHY WE LIKE IT: High-quality professional baking cups, shipping in a handy 24 pack of reusable liners, with each featuring a completely non-stick design.

Pros
  • Surpasses FDA food safety guidelines
  • Ships in handy 24 pack of reusable liners
  • Non-stick and dishwasher safe
Cons
  • Only 6 colors
  • Cannot be placed under broiler

These Freshware Silicone Baking Cup Liners are a high-grade professional product, shipping with 24 BPA-free reusable silicone liners that meet and exceed FDA food safety guidelines, adhering to the stricter German LFGB guidelines. We loved that these baking cup liners are non-stick and do not need oil to function and the fact that they are dishwasher safe when it comes time to clean.

Though the environmentally friendly 24 pack here is generous compared to similar reusable baking cup liners on the market, there are only six colors available, which is on the lower side. Additionally, though these baking cup liners are microwave and oven safe, the maximum recommended temperature is 446 degrees Fahrenheit, so they can’t be placed underneath the broiler.

How We Decided

To help narrow down to the above list, we focused primarily on two types of baking cup liners. There are disposable baking cup liners, which typically ship in large multipacks of up to 500. These are great for large baking projects, though each liner can only be used once and they often need a bit of oil to avoid sticking. Additionally, they don’t typically fare well in the microwave for reheating.

Then there are reusable baking cup liners. These liners are made from food-grade silicone and, as such, can withstand ultra-high temperatures and are usually microwave safe. Silicone baking cup liners tend to be freezer-safe, for long-term storage of baked goods, and dishwasher safe. The only downside here is that they often ship in smaller multipacks of around 12 to 24 liners.

Both types of baking cup liners are perfect for cupcakes and muffins, usually fitting in standard muffin pans. We took special care to include liners that were designed to hold jumbo-sized baked goods and those that were made for mini-sized baked goods. Finally, we liked baking cup liners that shipped in a large variety of bright and gorgeous color options.

Best Baking Cup Liner Buyer’s Guide

The Most Important Features to Consider

  1. Disposable Liners
    Disposable baking cup liners are a tried and true method of making cupcakes and muffins for many decades. They can stand relatively high temperatures, are manufactured with food-grade materials, and often ship in ultra-large multipacks of 300 to 500 liners, which make it easy to cater a large gathering with muffins and cupcakes. Of course, they must be thrown away after being used and they are not quite as non-stick as reusable liners, so we’d recommend giving them a bit of grease before popping them in the oven.
  2. Reusable Liners
    Reusable baking cup liners are often made from food-grade silicone and can be reused hundreds of times, often lasting many years before needing to be replaced. They can withstand ultra-high temperatures of as much as 500 degrees Fahrenheit and are often microwave safe, for the purposes of reheating, freezer safe, for storing baked goods, and dishwasher safe. They ship in small multipacks of 12 to 24, however, so it could be tricky to use reusable liners when preparing muffins or cupcakes for a wedding or party.
  3. Size
    Cupcakes and muffins come in all sizes and, as such, so do baking cup liners. If you are in the mood for jumbo-sized cupcakes and muffins, look for liners with a diameter of around 2.75 to three inches. If you want mini-sized cupcakes, look for baking cup liners with a diameter of around 1.75 inches. Standard-sized cupcakes and muffins are usually made with liners featuring a diameter of 2.25 inches, though this varies from company to company.

Baking Cup Liner FAQs

Should I spray my cupcake liners?

Not all baking cup liners need to be sprayed with oil or grease before baking, as many are designed to be non-stick. This is particularly true when it comes to reusable cups cake liners. However, there is no harm in adding a bit of extra grease if you want to be overly cautious.

Should I grease silicone muffin cups?

This is not necessary, generally speaking, as silicone is considered to be a non-stick material and muffins and cupcakes should pop right out. You can add a bit of cooking spray, however, if you want to be doubly sure that your baked goods will not stick.

Are silicone muffin cups safe?

Absolutely. Silicone baking cup liners are made from food grade silicone and often meet and exceed FDA guidelines regarding food safety. Silicone liners are also often microwave safe, freezer safe and dishwasher safe.

Who are the best baking cup liner manufacturers?

Our list features baking cup liners manufactured by renowned companies, such as Wilton and Mr. Miracle. Other high-grade baking cup liners that nearly made our list include Tulip Cupcake Liners and Bake Bright Greaseproof Cupcake Liners.

Also why not check out:

Lawrence Bonk

Lawrence Bonk is a copywriter with a decade of experience in the tech space, with columns appearing in Engadget, Huffington Post and CBS, among others. He has a cat named Cinnamon.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button
Close